Pro Property Partners
333 at the beach Pro Property Partners British International School, Phuket
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Phuket Opinion: Sending a clear message

PHUKET: The explanation by Phuket Governor Woonciew on Friday (May 19) that the driver of the tour speedboat ‘Thanathip Marine 555’ – which slammed into a channel marker in Chalong Bay on Wednesday, injuring 35 tourists – faces up to three years in jail if found guilty of negligence is a much welcomed and long overdue move. But it is, as always, only a part-improvement on the current state of dangerous and reckless driving by tour speedboat operators.

By The Phuket News

Sunday 21 May 2023, 09:00AM

Photo: via Phuket Info Center

Photo: via Phuket Info Center

Governor Narong explained to the press that the driver of the boat faces up to three years in jail or a fine of up to B60,000, or both, if he is found guilty of negligence that resulted in the collision.

First, let’s repeat “if” the driver is found guilty. Second, if the Governor’s move to announce serious possible penalties for such life-threatening behaviour is to count for anything, officials will have to break from the long-standing tradition of never announcing what penalties actually befall those held high as examples of justice being served.

It seems only obvious to prove to the public that justice has been served, though considering the actual penalty the court may hand down, that might just be a little too embarrassing.

But let’s not hold our breath for that. The Governor on Friday even shied away from actually naming the boat driver, who was plainly identified in the list names of those admitted to hospital for treatment of injuries sustained in the collision as Satit Maschai. That omission might be a better indicator of where this whole public performance is likely to end up.

Of course we will overlook the complicity of water safety officials, including Navy personnel and officers from the Phuket Marine Office itself, led by Phuket Marine Chief Natchapong Pranit, for not taking any action to enforce their own edict warning boat operators of the safety regulations in place – issued only just over two weeks ago.

Mr Natchapong publicly issued a notice, four pages in total, informing all boat operators of the safety regulations in effect ahead of the long weekend to celebrate HM The King’s birthday. However, after that weekend, tour speedboat operators went back to business as usual.

The notice was an oddity in itself. It was publicly posted on May 2, but marked as signed and dated on Apr 28, a week after a foreign passenger was injured by a “close pass” by a speedboat estimated to be travelling at about 25 knots in the approach to the channel leading to Royal Phuket Marina and Phuket Boat Lagoon.

The Phuket Marine Office made no public statement about that incident, despite the same harrowing nature of the reckless driving by tour speedboat operators using the channel there – and the fact the a tour speedboat collision in that same channel killed two children, a 12-year-old boy and a 9-year-old girl, on holiday with their families.

Apparently killing children is not enough to inspire Mr Natchapong to take reckless driving by tour speedboat operators seriously until there is yet another accident. Make no mistake, the fact that no one was killed in the collision with the channel marker on Wednesday is dumb luck.

Phuket marine officials can also add to their list the fact that in response to this week’s collision so far there has been no mention that by law since 2015 all passenger boats in Phuket carrying 24 or more passengers must have AIS (automatic identification system) tracking installed and switched on when in transit, relaying data to the ‘Phuket Yacht Control Centre’ at Chalong Pier, where inbound and outgoing boats are monitored.

The officers stationed at the ‘Phuket Yacht Control Centre’ at Chalong Pier even have a clear view of the tour speedboats flagrantly speeding across Chalong Bay, and still nothing has been done to curtail the dangerous behaviour of tour speedboats drivers.

Mr Natchapong, either the Phuket Marine Office has a special relationship of understanding with tour speedboat operators that everyone has to guess at, or tour speedboat operators are simply snubbing you and your entire office. You are just not important enough for them to do what you say the law is. They just don’t care.

The response by emergency services to the collision on Wednesday was excellent. It was nice to see senior local officials present on site as the injured were brought ashore, and the public reports of the investigation by officials so far has been a positive step forward in proving to the public that water safety, especially that involving tourists, is being taken seriously.

However, all that is only after the accident has happened. It is time to send a clear message to tour speedboat drivers in the hope of preventing the next one.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

* (Not Hotmail/Outlook)

Capt B | 22 May 2023 - 00:14:06

Although vessel speed was a big factor, it is now a known fact & not just in Thailand, for whatever reason, Captains fall asleep @ the wheel. AIS use is legislated. Fitment & use of a Bridge Navigational Watch Alarm System on all of these wiz bang tourist killers should be compulsory. A lot of gasoline onboard. Lucky they were not all burnt till death. Next time !!!

Paddy | 21 May 2023 - 11:56:21

Big fart, no shxx as usual , a 500 baht fine.

Kurt | 21 May 2023 - 10:24:59

Yes JohnC, answers on all your questions should be known/filed in drawer Chief Chalong Marine Office. And, ..are 3 person crew also trained/certified First Aid handlers? I doubt it.  Phuket, 'Worlds top tourist destination'? By the time that phrase becomes more ridicilous/absurd.. Phuket really have to scale itselfs down as tourist destination. Be more humble.

Kurt | 21 May 2023 - 10:06:42

Investigation  'Tanathip Marine 555' disaster must also include functioning/possible neglicence of 'Phuket Yacht Control Centre' Chalong pier. Was AIS working on boat and in Office? Was there VHF contact with  boat and warning given to reduce speed, while seeing the boat from office window? Chalong Pier Marine Office needs a big 'clean up' as it is indirect accessory of dis...

Kurt | 21 May 2023 - 09:42:35

Indeed, it looks like the Phuket Marine Office, with responsible boss Natchapong, has a special relationship/understanding with tour speedboat operators. It is just under the table and not written in a MoU.  :-)

Kurt | 21 May 2023 - 09:31:44

Great piece of Opinion. Specially that part of marine chief Natchapong and 'his' Phuket Marine Office at Chalong pier. Now we wait for info about AIS, the automatic tracking of tour speedboat 'Thanathip Marine 555' on her trip till the  Chalong Channel Marker.  And it is Phuket tradition that Officials who 'ORDER' not enforce their own edict warning. Warning out? Work done!

JohnC | 21 May 2023 - 09:17:27

Excellent article. Those 'home-made' speedboats moulded in backyards across the island as accidents waiting to happen. I wonder what other safety equipment was sadly lacking. No mention has been made about whether there were enough life jackets on board for every passenger and crew member. Fire extinguishers, basic first-aid kit, GPS/AIS tracking, EPIRB and SART should all be standard equi...


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Phuket cannabis businesses call for support

Absolutely it was never approved for recreational usage, but that provision got bent over backwar...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Facing down the taxi cartels

K Somchart is a brave man.. if he can change this then chapeaux.... just hope he will stay safe an...(Read More)

Phuket cannabis businesses call for support

stop issuing licences, stop online sell ( you can buy it anywhere online and could well be school k...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Facing down the taxi cartels

Perhaps the most widely held sentiment in Thailand is associated with the near universal disgust peo...(Read More)

Russian tourist drowns at Patong Beach

Same same, different year...some things will never change. Dangerous beaches, clueless visitors, and...(Read More)

Lao activist’s killing in Isan raises questions

Thailand's military regime is, and has always been incapable of conducting a "credible and ...(Read More)

Prayut allays fears over transfer of power

Now, MFP and Pheu Thai huddle/row over House Speaker job. In a democratic coalition they should givi...(Read More)

Russian tourist drowns at Patong Beach

Seen the weather predictions, the Life Guards should have been already patrolling that time. Not a s...(Read More)

Further crackdown on illegal foreigners underway

Raise Phuket image as safe/desirable(?) destination, better start sanation of PLTO/taxi cartels. The...(Read More)

Further crackdown on illegal foreigners underway

If everything starts with law full functioning Immigration, not provoking their own laws, like provi...(Read More)