The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search


Transport Minister ponders electric buses for Phuket, instead of light rail

Transport Minister ponders electric buses for Phuket, instead of light rail

PHUKET: Transport Minister Saksayam Chidchob has ordered the Mass Rapid Transit Authority (MRTA) to investigate the use of an electric bus network instead of developing the planned B35-billion Phuket Light Rail project. The move is hoped to reduce the cost of the project by B10bn so that the project funds can be approved by Cabinet and the project rolled into service by 2023.

tourismtransportconstructioneconomics
By The Phuket News

Saturday 7 November 2020, 05:04PM


Transport Minister Saksayam Chidchob arrives in Phuket last Saturday, ahead of the mobile Cabinet meeting on Tuesday. Photo: PR Phuket

Transport Minister Saksayam Chidchob arrives in Phuket last Saturday, ahead of the mobile Cabinet meeting on Tuesday. Photo: PR Phuket

A report by the respected Thai-language business journal Thansettakij reported yesterday (Nov 6) that Mr Saksayam ordered the review following his update on the project delivered to the mobile Cabinet meeting in Phuket on Tuesday (Nov 2).

Mr Saksaym said the move to consider using electric buses followed observing other mass-transit systems in cities abroad, reported Thansettakij.

The move would greatly reduce the cost of launching a mass-transit system. In Phuket’s case, it could save up to B10bn, he said.

“You would not have to build a rail and signaling system, and local people will benefit from the lower fares as well,” he said.

“However, as time passes it would become less cost-effective as old buses will need to be replaced,” he noted.

Mr Saksayam explained that as the project was still in its development stage, the MRTA was not bound to develop specifically a rail system. A bus system could be launched instead, he said.

“Looking at the latest study results we found that only about 39,000 people a day would use the mass-transit system, which could be a bus system at first. Initially, it would be a special express bus format,” Mr Saksayam said.

The route would remain the same as the current plans for the light rail, Mr Saksayam noted.

The express bus network would be able to use the same central reservation area along Thepkrasattri Rd where the light-rail is planned to be built, he said.

“There should not be any problems. The MRTA has discussed with the Department of Highways about removing the central traffic island, reworking the road surface and the installation of barriers to keep the buses separate from general traffic,” he added.

“But what the MRTA has to consider further is creating stations for passengers to use. Is there a need for additional adjustments? Or can the same number of stations at the same locations be used? And can some places also be used for commercial use? 

“In addition, it must be considered what kind of adjustments must be made where general traffic crosses the current route, such as whether a tunnel will be needed or whether money could be saved by having traffic lights manage the crossroads, which would allow the express bus to go first,” he added.

Mr Saksayam cautioned people from jumping to conclusions about whether or not a bus system will be launched instead. The concept is only under consideration, he pointed out.

“It should take a while to consider which format to choose instead of a tram system,” he said. 

Of note, while reports of an electric bus system identical to that first posted by Thansettakij yesterday are now circulating online, the Ministry of Transport has yet to announce the move through any of its formal channels. Likewise, the MRTA has yet to announce that it is to look at the cost-saving manoeuvre.

The Public Relations Department also failed to note the option of electric buses is being investigated. In its report of Mr Saksayam’s visit to Phuket, the only news it had to report was that the budget had increased by B400 million, to B 35.201bn. The reason for the budget increase was not explained.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

CAPTCHA

Kurt | 09 November 2020 - 08:52:04

There are on Phuket no ideas/initiatives of replacing old busses and trucks. See all of them that are blasting dangerous black smoke today. Obligate them at least having good working filter systems.

JohnC | 08 November 2020 - 11:55:57

It is good to consider alternatives especially more eco friendly ones. However this is missing the whole point of building the light rail network. Phuket's badly congested and maintained road network is a joke at the best of times. Expecting the electric buses will provide a better service on the same bad roads does not make one bit of sense. Stick to the rail idea so it has a chance of workin...

Kurt | 08 November 2020 - 10:55:49

Good reconsideration, Minister. I already wrote 05 Nov. perhaps a combination of electric- and trolly busses are better and more flexible  alternative than a light rail. Imagine maintenance of light rail or a truck flips and blocks the rail? Whole rail system is than paralyzed. And: The reason for B400 million budget rise not clear? Simple, for kick backs and 'further studies'.

PhuketRe | 08 November 2020 - 07:21:59

This tram project was ridiculous from the start. Just make normal electric busses that can access many different places without separate lanes. There is enough traffic jam on the bypass road, highway and other roads - dont need to reduce lanes. The saved billions spend on making underpasses in the roundabout monument, Thalang and to widen other roads - this will be of benefit to everybody!

Fascinated | 07 November 2020 - 20:30:26

that will be another 40m baht spent on a 'feasibility study' then, 555.

 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Phuket Opinion: A storm is brewing

Remember that article here 2 months ago about the PPAO offering loans to tourism business to help re...(Read More)


Philippines suspends Thailand travel

@Xivi Finocchio,you are really not the sharpest tool in the shed ! The Delta variant is found all...(Read More)


Phuket Sandbox driving employment opportunities in private boat charter industry

@xivirus. If you are born in Phuket then you are showing everyone what an embarrassment you are to a...(Read More)


Body of man who fell at Sarasin Bridge after entry denial found

With the amount of locals who lose their lives simply because they don't know how to swim why do...(Read More)


Hotel operators hopeful for recovery to start in H2 2021

Interesting that the graph snow the occupancy rate dropping dramaticlly before 2019......(Read More)


Phuket marks 18 new COVID cases for second successive day

Covid-19 cases are reaching the red line of 90 weekly cases to begin sandbox closing. ...(Read More)


Another Phuket rule change: Negative COVID test results must be issued in past 72 hours

I left Phuket over 2 weeks ago to Chiangmai. I am a resident in Phuket and I have a work permit. I a...(Read More)


Philippines suspends Thailand travel

Any country that used Xinovac CRAP is NOW dealing with Delta WUHAN Virus, including the Philippines....(Read More)


Phuket Sandbox driving employment opportunities in private boat charter industry

My sources are on the ground. I know exactly what is going on. If you'd followed my comments you...(Read More)


As COVID plagues Thailand, PETA calls for all live-animal markets to be closed

๑Xi DK was supporting you so why do put him down. I think the problem is that you have been eatin...(Read More)