Kata Rocks
THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Phuket Poll: Should Thailand build the Kra Canal?

Phuket Poll: Should Thailand build the Kra Canal?

PHUKET: Since The Phuket News posted its special report on the Kra Canal earlier this month, the potential mega-project has rated high in the news with international press reports from Malaysia and Singapore attempting to downplay the importance the canal could have for Thailand.

opiniontransporteconomicsenvironmentconstructionmarinepollution
By The Phuket News

Wednesday 14 February 2018, 09:33AM


The current proposed Kra Canal route 9A cuts across the Kra Isthmus about 100 kilometres south of Phuket. Image: Google Maps / Courtesy of Pakdee Tanapura

The current proposed Kra Canal route 9A cuts across the Kra Isthmus about 100 kilometres south of Phuket. Image: Google Maps / Courtesy of Pakdee Tanapura

The report by The Phuket News put forward the arguments in favour of the canal put forward by two key figures of the Thai Canal Association for Study and Development – Royal Thai Navy Adm (Rtd) Soopakorn Boonranadiloak and Pakdee Tanapura.

The pair, as guest speakers at a British Chamber of Commerce in Thailand (BCCT) Phuket Business Dinner event on Feb 1, confirmed that the association had filed a formal request to the current government to undertake a full feasibility study to make the Kra Canal a reality. (See story here.)

Since then the topic has gained momentum. The Bangkok Post followed up on Sunday (Feb 11) with confirmation from Government spokesman Lt Gen Sansern Kaewkamnerd that the government is currently reviewing the proposal.

However, Gen Sansern pointed out that the project was currently not a priority for the Thai government.

He also sagely pointed out for people to be wary of campaigns blankly saying that the project is going ahead. (See story here.)

In response, government news agencies in Malaysia and Singapore this week quickly ran their own truncated versions of this report highlighting these two facts, but omitting that Gen Sansern had confirmed that the Thai Government is reviewing the proposal.

What’s ironic is that Channel News Asia, owned by the Singapore Government, and The Straits Times – not once, but twice – both ran a story posted by Malaysian state news agency Bernama. (See stories here and here.)

Malaysia’s understanding of the importance of the Kra Canal is clear. It is the Maritime Institute of Malaysia that has forecast that the Strait of Malacca, already the busiest shipping lane in the world, will exceed its shipping capacity by 2025 – just seven years from now.

Hence Malaysia is currently ploughing ahead with expanding its facilities at Port Klang, east of Kuala Lumpur, where containers are planned to be loaded onto high-speed freight trains.

What is obvious from the press attention from Malaysia and Singapore is how heavily the negative aspects of the Kra Canal were highlighted in the stories they ran, which only served to highlight how important the project is to them.

For example, the reports stressed that Prime Minister Gen Prayut Chan-o-cha had “emphasized” that the Thai Government “did not have a policy” for the Kra Canal – an odd observation since the government is still only reviewing the latest proposal.

BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET

The reports also highlighted that Government Spokesperson Gen Sansern said that Thailand currently had other priorities – and did not currently have the funds to build the canal – another odd observation since Public-Private Partnerships and “build-operate-transfer” projects are how Thailand traditionally sources the funds for mega-projects, not paying wholesale out of pocket.

Also, while the reports by Thailand’s southern neighbours noted that Thailand is currently short of funds to build the canal, they also neglected to point out that only last year PM Prayut pushed through the B179-billion deal to build the high-speed rail link between Bangkok and Nakhon Ratchasima. (See story here.)

In comparison, the Kra Canal at this stage is projected to cost B55bn.

The Kra Canal project does have a long way to go before becoming a reality, and many key concerns, including as The Phuket News readers have pointed out, environmental issues, must be addressed before Thailand takes the plunge.

On that note, one point that has not been made plain is that all ships entering and exiting the Strait of Malacca already pass Phuket in the 290 kilometres of water between here and the closest point on Sumatra.

To all this The Phuket News asks readers the simple question, “Should Thailand build the Kra Canal?”

Responses available in the poll are:

  • Yes – the time is now, start building it.
  • Yes – but only if approved via a full feasibility study and a full Environmental Impact Assessment, including public approval and feedback meetings, is conducted by a respected independent organisation.
  • Not yet – growth in global shipping dictates that the Kra Canal will be needed sometime in the future, but not just yet.
  • No – the entire project is a waste of taxpayer’s money and endangers the environment and tourism to the Andaman region.

To vote in the poll, click here.

If your preferred response is not listed, feel free to add it in the comments section below.

To see the results of our previous poll, which asked, “Do you believe in Bitcoin?”, click here.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

CAPTCHA

Kurt | 14 February 2018 - 10:25:42

No Kra Canal building now
First study possibility of the sea route north of Russia and Siberia, as due to climate change that route becomes more and more ice free. 
That route seems to become ice free before a Kra Canal would be realized

A Kra Canal study should only be done by a international team of experts under auspices of UN. ( for reality matters instead of local 'budget-dreaming...

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Body of second missing Filipino found off Phuket

Koh Keow (Green Island) is 1 of 2 small islands in the south of Phuket next to Promthep Cape. Isnt i...(Read More)


Phuket readies for HM King’s birthday

Fascinated, it is clearly mentioned that no ban on alcohol sales has been announced SO FAR. What n...(Read More)


Cross Hotels & Resorts inks deal for new Phuket venue

To be clear, they are taking over an existing hotel, not adding a new one to Patong's already th...(Read More)


Phuket Poll: Environmental damage, prices too high

And what would Mr.K like officials to do about those high prices? Force everyone to sell food at low...(Read More)


PM Prayut calls out Phuket van driver for overcharging Aussie tourists

What has this water shortage talk from Mr.K to do with this article? And as he knows that there wil...(Read More)


Phuket airport van B3k fare ‘just a misunderstanding’, say police

As Mr.K knows the prices so well,maybe he could tell us what the published prices are at those desk...(Read More)


Phuket Opinion: Hit the dog

No one would deny that this was an appalling thing to do, but if you want to talk about legal ramifi...(Read More)


Phuket readies for HM King’s birthday

Err Capn Jack READ the last sentence there is CLEARLY mention of it....(Read More)


Bridging Supply: Officials reveal B3.5bn proposal to resolve island’s water shortage woes

Ahhhh Dkk- still as arrogant as ever I read. I've been waiting years for YOUR constructive comme...(Read More)


Phuket Poll: Environmental damage, prices too high

Great Phuket Poll. Now waiting for response of Phuket Officialdom as the outcome is significant. Sic...(Read More)