BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search


Phuket Opinion: The problem with being held responsible for everything

Phuket Opinion: The problem with being held responsible for everything

PHUKET: This week we’re going to do something you’re don’t see often: we’re going into bat for the Phuket Governor, Narong Woonciew.

opinion
By The Phuket News

Sunday 3 October 2021, 09:00AM


Phuket Governor Narong Woonciew at a Phuket Community Welfare Organization Network event earlier this week titled ‘Phuket People Unite, leaving no person behind’. Photo: PR Phuket

Phuket Governor Narong Woonciew at a Phuket Community Welfare Organization Network event earlier this week titled ‘Phuket People Unite, leaving no person behind’. Photo: PR Phuket

The easing of restrictions this week for people to enter Phuket, and most notably the easing of restrictions to allow venues that serve food to also serve alcohol and provide live music – both measures long overdue to many people on the island – did not come by anywhere as quickly as it was played out in the public sphere.

There is no way that the Governor publicly issued a written formal request one day to see the easing of measures requested relaxed the very next day. It just does not happen that quickly. The easing of the restrictions in effect in Phuket was not instant; those conversations had already happened.

The most pertinent point Governor Narong included in his missive, at risk of embarrassing his superiors in Bangkok, was, “... as restaurants and food establishments in hotels and other food or beverage outlets serve Phuket Sandbox tourists, the tourists are affected. The service is inconsistent with the guidelines for promoting tourism in Phuket.”

Here we see the giant gap between Bangkok-appointed officials who are ordered to follow their masters’ bidding. If the position of Governor were an actually elected position, as a politician the governor would have been informing the people what his actual efforts were and laying the responsibility at the feet of those actually responsible for the rules being enforced.

While provincial governors may enforce stricter COVID prevention measures than those set out by the CCSA (Center for COVID Administration Situation), under the emergency decree, even as governor, Mr Narong is not allowed to relax any measures without Bangkok’s consent.

He must follow his superiors orders, and that includes not telling the people exactly who in Bangkok has decided that people in Phuket will have to continue to suffer deepening personal financial hardship under the measures extended. Those thinking that the governor should ‘break the code’ and just do what he feels right, even if what the people are asking for might bring more harm than good, may not be fully appreciating that doing so is pointless. He will just be replaced by someone who will toe the line – there is no secret in that.

CBRE Phuket

This is the problem of being held responsible for everything in Phuket when everything needs monitoring and when those “above” you are making decisions they are not being held responsible for.

The position of Governor is to ensure that Bangkok-mandated policy is implemented in Phuket, and to carry feedback from the people of Phuket back to Bangkok. The latter Governor Narong has clearly done. As early as last year he travelled to Bangkok to deliver the message in person how much the island has been suffering under the COVID control policies, and we have all seen the lack of impact that has had. That is not the governor’s fault.

All of this is not to exempt our governor from being the focus of criticisms. That is his job. And none of this excuses the current national administration for its many, many failings. This is just to highlight the reality of the theatre the governor must operate in.

And this is certainly not to excuse any krieng jai, the Thai practice of not upsetting the social order by questioning any person in a perceived position of superiority, either officially or socially, which many Thais uphold to be an integral aspect of Thai culture.

There are now plenty of Thais who believe that there is nothing impolite about asking those responsible legitimate questions about policies that are having a direct impact on their lives. How the questions are asked is matter of politeness, not just the fact that questions are being asked.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

CAPTCHA

Kurt | 04 October 2021 - 09:20:34

....As usual the ruling class don't give a damn for the Thai lower class. Fine Opinion piece in  enlightening that it is not the Governor who is responsible for the misery on Phuket. Same time this Opinion demote Governor just to a ceremonial figure who sits his time out until he can retire.

Kurt | 03 October 2021 - 23:52:23

So,, a Governor is just a Bangkok puppet, a kind of 'hatch' ? That is not much of help for the many desperate Phuket Thai inhabitants. In Bangkok many Ministries are 'involved', so no one responsible for Phuket misery. The perfect Thai way not to handle matters the proper way with heart/passion for the 'no have's'. As usual ruling class doesn't give a damn for the l...

Christy Sweet | 03 October 2021 - 14:59:26

Krieng Jai- along with the prevalent patriarchal religion is all about oppression of the masses. The former tells you it's rude to counter, the latter instructs satisfaction with this arrangement. Dump them both, please.  

Sir Burr | 03 October 2021 - 13:42:59

The reason that the governor is appointed and not elected is to prevent the inevitable corruption once high powered, Phuket natives. Bangkok does not want an official in the pocket of "dark forces".

jurgphuket | 03 October 2021 - 12:31:47

The gouvernor of Phuket has done a good job to lift the alcohol ban, which always has been only useless.
He should also Lift the Sandbox Quarantine completely and only let vaccinated and tested people on the island. Then the tourism will really come back and brings the people of Phuket jobs and money

JohnC | 03 October 2021 - 09:25:19

[the Thai practice of not upsetting the social order by questioning any person in a perceived position of superiority, either officially or socially] What a load of BS. It's nothing to do with being consideration (Greng Jai เกรงใจ) or respect. It is all to do with fearing for their positions, and in some cases their lives, if they don't suck up to their superiors.

 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
PM presses Asean to reopen

Thailand- The epitome of Disaster Capitalism. Just wait until the Gulf inundates Bangkok-they'll...(Read More)


Incentive offered for foreign investment in property

10, 000 foreigners- have they been using TAT's magic calculator? Cloud cuckoo land. Looking at t...(Read More)


Incentive offered for foreign investment in property

In non-thai thinking 'property' means house/condo, including the land below/around it ( gard...(Read More)


Incentive offered for foreign investment in property

Psst Rich people don't want to live in developing nations with corrupt police. They can afford h...(Read More)


PM presses Asean to reopen

He also said that his kidx are in urgent need of upgrading their luxury cars from 2021 to 2022 model...(Read More)


Phuket New Year Countdown: Bocelli confirmed, Lisa to be decided in Krabi

Wasting Taxpayers money on govt's stupid plans doesn't make much sense, does it? Spend th...(Read More)


Thailand Pass to entice more international tourists

stupidity is in fact more dangerous than the virus and the bad news is that there are no vaccines yo...(Read More)


Phuket marks 83 new COVID cases, four more deaths

No mystery why flu cases are down when people have largely stopped sticking their fingers in their ...(Read More)


Solving Phuket’s plastic problem: 7 reasons to stop drinking bottled water

Simple. Charge a 10 baht deposit on ANY plastic beverage. Set up recycling centers in every neighbo...(Read More)


Solving Phuket’s plastic problem: 7 reasons to stop drinking bottled water

Reality check here pal, it's not "us" doing this. There is zero awareness in general T...(Read More)