Chef’s Market
Chef’s Market 333 at the beach British International School, Phuket Pro Property Partners
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search


Phuket Opinion: Stopping the sprawl

PHUKET: The idea of building a seven-story hotel in the middle of a quiet, undeveloped neighbourhood in Bang Tao has shone a light on a critical issue bubbling away in Phuket for years, but has yet to receive any recognition from local officials: urban sprawl.

opinionconstructioneconomicsenvironmenttourismnatural-resourcesproperty
By The Phuket News

Sunday 25 September 2022, 09:00AM


Inland areas in Cherng Talay are increasingly being redesignated as ’urban’. Image: PSU Phuket campus

Inland areas in Cherng Talay are increasingly being redesignated as ’urban’. Image: PSU Phuket campus

The fight by residents in Soi Pasak 6, Bang Tao, does not stand alone. Many other areas are facing the same problem, especially now that the prospect of tourists returning in numbers is becoming an increasing reality.

A study of land use by a research team at the Prince of Songkla University (PSU) identified that Phuket lost 10.051 square kilometres of forest conservation areas and 15.598 square kilometres of rural and agricultural areas to residential development in four short years from 2005 to 2009. How much more in green areas were lost during the years of skyrocketing tourism from 2015 to 2019 is anyone’s guess.

Many would blame Thailand’s zoning regulations, or lack of, for the mess. Despite what many expats might believe, Thailand actually does have zoning regulations, and it is not the lack of enforcement of the zoning regulations that has allowed the cancerous sprawl to continue – it is the fact that the zoning regulations themselves allow such piecemeal development with local officials having no legal mechanism to deny construction approval.

This was finally recognised and introduction of an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) required for each major project was hoped to address the issue. Yet, nearly as always with bureaucracy in Thailand, the regulation of EIAs themselves has been found lacking.

The copy of the questionnaire sent to local residents in the Soi Pasak 6 area in Bang Tao was an odd animal indeed. While 22 pages long, the questionnaire asked local residents their ages, occupations and preexisting medical conditions, how they disposed of waste and wastewater and even if any children living in the house attended a local school.

The document did not explain why this information was relevant when the EIA was supposed to be addressing the potential impact of the construction project on the local residents and the local environment. It is not supposed to be focussing on the local residents already living in the area. The document read more like a cross between a marketing research survey and a medical insurance application form whereby information could be solicited in the hope of denying a claim later.

Such a lax in controls opens the door to entire communities to be under threat from commercial or even industrial development, to the point that an international school on the east coast is fighting to prevent a slaughterhouse being allowed to open within 400 metres of the school’s grounds. It also undermines Phuket’s ability to lure buyers of high-end properties costing tens of millions of baht each when there is no guarantee of what may be built in the immediate vicinity just a handful of years later.

One land-use research team from PSU Phuket campus warned a decade ago, “The development of tourism is a key driving force of a rapid land use and land cover changes in Phuket. Weak policy enforcement was marked in this study, pointing out an inconsistency between practical land uses in 2009 and the purposes of land uses set by the Phuket Island Town Planning Policy in 2005.

“Ongoing expansions of urban lands without serious control and enforced regulation may have brought undesirable impacts on natural disasters and biodiversity losses. A strong and effective collaborative between locals, private business sectors and government authorities is required to ensure sustainable tourism development coupled with environmental protection,” the research team added.

More recently, Phattanan Pisutwimol, as President of the Phuket Real Estate Association (P-REA), in 2020 warned of poor controls on development when SorPorKor land use was deregulated to allow commercial developments.

“If we’re not careful other buildings such as shopping malls or other types of buildings might be allowed, and this new construction, if it is not considered well, will affect the environment and forest areas in Phuket,” Mr Phattanan said.

“These new rules are supposed to protect Phuket’s main source of income, but instead they may jeopardise it,” he added.

The message was clear: if you allow Phuket’s green areas to be killed, you threaten Phuket’s tourism industry and Phuket’s property industry. When you have property developers themselves calling for restraint in further development, the alarm bell is well and truly ringing.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

* (Not Hotmail/Outlook)
CAPTCHA

christysweet | 26 September 2022 - 12:27:02

Any property developers concerned are so only to keep inventory low, prices high. Stop buying into their environmental exploitation or we're all going to suffer badly. 

christysweet | 26 September 2022 - 10:10:46

Has an EIA ever said 'no' ?   Over the last month likely 25 or so rai of  old growth forest was wiped out  in Layan meaning more  condos on the way with  one stalled project creating a blight and another' eco'  project  under construction- there will be hundreds of unsold units. NO one wants to  vacation in urban sprawl esp when the beaches are covered in trash. 

Kurt | 26 September 2022 - 07:33:46

Typo. Read for 'lusty' --> 'Pleasure garden'.

Kurt | 26 September 2022 - 00:26:02

Prab, before starting on the make of that tunnel, they have to try to repair Patak Rd on the Kata Hill first. That is now already 2 years in the waiting room.  :-) A piece of road less that 200 meters. That tunnel is just a conversation study money trough so far.

DeKaaskopp | 25 September 2022 - 21:16:21

Yes Kurt.I agree.Let Phuket be lusty !

Prab | 25 September 2022 - 11:00:15

amen to that..lol....let make a tunnel from katu to patong first though...

Kurt | 25 September 2022 - 09:46:38

Show me 1 Thai law or regulation what is found not lacking. It is almost or they do make them that way with purpose, to give room for corruption, advantage taking politicians, powerful business people, and lawyers who make a fine living of the 'lacking'.

Kurt | 25 September 2022 - 09:20:26

Great Opinion piece. Well, as a large percentage of Phuket legal- and illegal hotels are still closed, let them open first and see how the occupation rate will be coming ..'High Season'..  Decide next year or it is needed to build more hotels and destroy more of what is left over of what Phuket suppose to be,.. Lusty and Green.

 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
China cities under heavy policing after protests

PN reporting; Thu 24, Sun 27, Tue 29, just about China's Covid happening. Seems the Chinese vacc...(Read More)


PHUKET XTRA: VIDEO: Drinking hours proposal denied, ‘Prab’ Patong Road, Phuketians reach Mt Everest Base Camp! || November 28

Why do many oppose longer Bangla hours. Or, selling land for new roads? Money. The money that others...(Read More)


Landowners step up for new Kathu-Srisoonthorn road

Why do many oppose longer Bangla hours. Or, selling land for new roads? Money. The money that others...(Read More)


Landowners step up for new Kathu-Srisoonthorn road

Did the Prab-Keesin road builders submitted a request to the PPAO to build the 'Prab Rd'? Di...(Read More)


Raise your guard against dangerous new COVID wave, government warns

On one hand the Thai do everything to get tourists in for their money, regardless Covid-19 thinking....(Read More)


Thailand Pride Parade 2022 gets underway

And how about " White Pride" parades? I am sure many commenter on here would like to join...(Read More)


Landowners step up for new Kathu-Srisoonthorn road

No such thing as a free lunch, I know people who donated the land for a road and it pushed up the pr...(Read More)


Raise your guard against dangerous new COVID wave, government warns

Do Phuket hospitals have the newest formula and are expats eligible for the vaccination?...(Read More)