The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Phuket Opinion: Same old games

PHUKET: News of police ‘robbing’ foreigners through traffic fines touched a nerve this week, as the Phuket Provincial Police felt compelled to publicly respond to just one post online, by a Thai.

By The Phuket News

Sunday 28 November 2021, 09:00AM

The photo posted online this week that sparked anger over police raking in fines from tourists. Photo: via Phuket Provincial Police

The photo posted online this week that sparked anger over police raking in fines from tourists. Photo: via Phuket Provincial Police

The response prompted a strong reaction from the foreign community in Phuket, and abroad, noting that the same old game was nothing new, already well known for years.

The claim by the Phuket Provincial Police that the traffic police officers in question in the post online were only enforcing traffic regulations to help reduce the number of accidents on the roads, hence helping to preserve life and limb of foreigners and Thais alike, was laughable.

If the police were sincere about reducing road accidents in Phuket we would actually see moving violations served. As for the strong emphasis in the response that the police are not overly selective in targeting foreigners, that notion would be dispelled by spending just one afternoon watching police at Chalong Circle performing their “road safety duty”.

The fact that the public response from the Phuket Provincial Police was unsigned by any named officer, or any official for that matter, only strengthens the perception that police are going to keep their distance from this one. Maybe they already know what everyone else understands.

Like any well-run scam, the systemic fining of foreign tourists for traffic violations – namely not having a valid driver’s licence recognised by Thai authorities – depends on the rules actually being genuine and posted publicly to safeguard those profiting from the operation. Not doing so is called is called entrapment.

This the police certainly have in their favour. Warnings about the requirements for being able to legally drive in Thailand are posted in travel advisories, on travel blogs, chat rooms and elsewhere all over the internet. The problem is that many tourists do not bother checking before coming here, and the police know it.

A genuine effort to prevent the fallout from tourists telling all their friends about their “Amazing Thailand” experience in being fined by the Royal Thai Police has been launched before . The campaign targeted motorbike rental shops to ensure that tourists have the appropriate licence to legally drive in Thailand before being allowed to rent a vehicle out to the tourist. The irony was that the aim of the campaign was to focus on keeping tourists legal, not on the officers raking in the fines. (See stories here, here and here.)

One idea promoted for many years is to warn tourists of this requirement in the destination arrival briefing while they are still on the plane on their approach to Phuket, that is while they are still a “captive audience”.

The same arrival briefing should also warn them of the need to wear a face mask while in public areas in Thailand, and that the initial fine is up to B1,000, not B20,000 as widely announced earlier this week. That should help correct errant behaviour by and – and onto – unsuspecting tourists.

Expats here have little excuse. Learn the law, stay legal and do not give corrupt officers the opportunity to land themselves a bonus. If the officer is intent on extortion, force him to go the mile. The extra effort required goes against the motivation for a shakedown. The idea is to get easy money.

Once the officer is forced to file a genuine report for the alleged transgression, the opportunity to make any extra money is gone and the accused has the right to deny the claim against them by the police in court, just like anywhere else.

That is the best advice we can offer.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Svcoquette | 02 December 2021 - 16:44:04

I've found the best way to avoid paying a bribe is to stay calm and respectful and ask for a receipt. When the answer is "no receipt" I hold up my phone and money and say OK I take photo for receipt. Has worked every time. Assuming you have all the paperwork, proper license and helmet, which I do.

Fascinated | 02 December 2021 - 16:15:18

Spread to Kamala now as well. At least twenty Thais went past with no helmets but the first foreigner was pulled straight away. They can deny all they want but we know the truth.

lelecuneo | 28 November 2021 - 16:54:32

why would the police no check all local busines instead? the 4th wave is coming and hope this time we willhave a rid of all those dodgy mafiousrun businesses around here 

fulviahf | 28 November 2021 - 16:23:27

They need their tea money to buy their Ferrari .....

christysweet | 28 November 2021 - 14:48:17

Phuket locals are the mayors and  police, the taxis, the scams and rip-offs- or they are related by marriage to it.  Only thing that will change it is a complete 180 from tourism. Cue non-ending pandemic.

CaptainJack69 | 28 November 2021 - 12:10:23

The locals have always hated the insidious greed, nepotism and corruption of Phuket. The hope was that the emergence from the COVID darkness could bring about a new start with change for the better. Instead we are seeing a mad dash by police, politicians and taxi drivers to not just return to their old ways but to make up for almost 2 years of lost 'income' as well.

JohnC | 28 November 2021 - 09:24:23

If this is the best advice PN can give us, just curious if you have any advice for the members of the RTP stormtroopers inc.?

JohnC | 28 November 2021 - 09:22:07

If you have ever experienced going to court in this country then you won't be in a hurry to go back there, especially over an alleged extortion attempt for a traffic violation. You. Will. Not. Win.


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Phuket Town pedestrian crossings get safety makeover

@christysweet What are 'presto people?'...(Read More)

Scathing Phuket hospitel report spurs action

...white light restaurants, and must renew permits for the silly reason the alcohol time window goes...(Read More)

Phuket Town pedestrian crossings get safety makeover

Without traffic lights pedestrian crossings in any country are a hazard for everyone involved Stop...(Read More)

Scathing Phuket hospitel report spurs action

Very good famous journalist Jonathan Miller shines his view about the sloppy nonsense Phuket hospit...(Read More)

Phuket vows tough action on unmasked tourists

You would think in all fairness that all people not wearing masks would be prosecuted, not only tour...(Read More)

Scathing Phuket hospitel report spurs action

Cue inbound 'defamation' charges for the Sunday Times exposing the truth. The whole thing is...(Read More)

Foreigner shot at Patong resort

@JohnC- nice bit of casual racism going on there. Any proof to back up your comment? One wonders why...(Read More)

Scathing Phuket hospitel report spurs action

most of those hospitel do not even have proper hotel licence.... that a fact......(Read More)

Scathing Phuket hospitel report spurs action

thos hospitel are all local run businesses, therefore they all are holes and crappy places....there ...(Read More)

Phuket Town pedestrian crossings get safety makeover

Things can change - and quickly. Look at Times Square in NY City. The Mayor started enforcing the s...(Read More)