The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Phuket Opinion: Corruption, and the Big Joke

Phuket Opinion: Corruption, and the Big Joke

PHUKET: Bhumivisan Kasemsuk, Director of the Foreign Affairs Department of the Office of Public Sector Anti-Corruption Commission (PACC) of Thailand, was in Phuket this week to assure local consuls and investors that corruption was being taken seriously again, and to encourage complaints of corruption to be filed with the PACC.

By The Phuket News

Sunday 27 September 2020, 09:00AM

Bhumivisan Kasemsuk, Director of the Foreign Affairs Department of the Office of Public Sector Anti-Corruption Commission (PACC) of Thailand, in Phuket this week. Photo: PR Phuket

Bhumivisan Kasemsuk, Director of the Foreign Affairs Department of the Office of Public Sector Anti-Corruption Commission (PACC) of Thailand, in Phuket this week. Photo: PR Phuket

The meeting, held at the Wyndham Grand Phuket Kalim Bay north of Patong on Thursday (Sept 24) to launch the “Complaint Center for Foreign Investors”, with a special lecture on the topic “Roles and missions of the Office of the PACC for foreign investors”, aimed to inspire confidence that Phuket, and Thailand, was a safe place to invest their money.

Present to hear the message were foreign investors and representatives from the private sector doing business in Phuket as well as representatives of foreign consulates in Phuket, including those representing Estonia, France, Germany, the Republic of Korea Switzerland and the UK.

Also called to be present for the occasion were representatives of the relevant government agencies in the area, including provincial officials and officers from the Provincial Commercial Office, Customs, Immigration, the Provincial Ombudsman’s Office, the Provincial Office of the Ministry of Justice as well as local police and municipal officials.

At least the right people were in the room, though perhaps the message to remind people that complaints against corruption could be filed was for the latter, not the former.

Surely foreign consuls and foreigners doing business in Phuket are aware that complaints against corruption can be filed, foreigners just don’t. There are many good reasons for this, first and foremost is that it is pointless, and second doing so only exposes the person filing the complaint to retribution by the very people the complaint is being filed against. When the allegedly corrupt person is a uniform-wearing official, it would be safer to just deal with the problem yourself.

The move to try to instill some confidence among foreigners to bring their money to Thailand comes as the Immigration Bureau tries to balance its two faces of policing foreigners in the country with providing a fees-based service to people wanting to stay in the country. This they have not achieved well.

A sharp warning earlier this week spelled out that any foreigners who have not reported themselves to extend their stay by the end of the visa amnesty yesterday would see them face a daily fine B500 overstay for each day they remain unreported comes after months of making it clear that tourists will be welcome to stay – but not one word of any support for foreigners who have invested in setting up a business in Thailand has arrived. Every foreigner who has set up a business in Phuket and who is now suffering due to the COVID-19 economic meltdown now finds themselves unable to satisfy the Immigration Bureau’s requirements in order for such foreigners to stay. These foreigners, exactly the same type of people Mr Bhumivisan is hoping to lure to Thailand, are facing dire, uncertain futures at the hands of immigration regulations.

To paint a picture of how trustworthy this situation is, by wonderful coincidence former Immigration Bureau chief Surachate Hakparn this week filed his legal plaint against the prime minister for illegally having him removed from his post and transferred to an inactive post at the Prime Minister’s Office.

How are these connected? Simple, Pol Maj Gen Surachate was transferred hot on the heels of him ordering immigration officers to no longer accept “tips” from foreigners at airports to facilitate their entry to the country.

UWC Thailand

The practice of immigration officers “accepting tips” from international tourists in order to “fast track” their processing at airports started gaining speed in 2013, as the Chinese hordes started to flock to Thailand. The practice hit its peak by 2017-18, when at Phuket airport it was finally admitted that officers were accepting “tips” of B200 cash “per person”. The payments were accepted “in baht or yuan” – as if any other nationalities than Chinese nationals happen to be carrying yuan  when they landed in Thailand.

To put that in perspective, Airports of Thailand themselves estimated that more than 60,760 passengers a day passed through Phuket International Airport over the New Year period for 2017-18, arriving on some 360 flights a day at the airport.

Now factor in that this was standard practice at each airport in the country, and carried out throughout the whole year.

In October 2018, Mr Surachate put an end to this income stream, then he was shunted to the Prime Minister’s Office. No official reason was given, but considering the immediate history, it was not a surprise to anyone. The Immigration Bureau had built a multi-billion-baht money-making machine with no reason to explain to anyone exactly how much money had been made or where that money went.

The PACC launched no investigation into this, and now the PACC wants people to believe that complaints against corruption will be treated seriously. Seriously, foreigners already know that complaints against corruption in Thailand are nothing more than a political weapon – nothing more. Recent headlines prove that to be still true.

Mr Bhumivisan wants to help improve Thailand’s general “corruption perception index” ranking. Well, the problem is that the general “perception” is that any problem can be “fixed” for a price, unless the problem becomes political.

As always, what is needed is a culture shift from the ground up and the formalisation of any extra revenue streams for any officials – and the public publishing of officials assets at each so-called “transfer” so people can see how much money was made during the officers last posting.

Most people anywhere do not trust politicians, but in Thailand the truth is that most people do not trust officials, including Thais. Of course there are good people working for the government, the problem is that to protect yourself from exploitation you have err on the side of caution, and very few of the honest officials climb the ranks to any position of authority because they simply are not corrupt enough to afford their next promotion. Corruption tends to win at every turn.

With that, we wish Mr Bhumivisan the very best of luck in convincing anyone that corruption is being taken seriously in Thailand.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Kurt | 29 September 2020 - 13:51:07

Seen the list of  Thai representatives and relevant ( uniformed as well) agencies present at meeting I am sure the Director of PACC not crossed invisible thai boundaries or overstepped  his 'authority'. At the end just a friendly meeting of 'us know us'. No harm done. Things remain as they are. Sabai-sabai.

Kurt | 28 September 2020 - 11:06:43

@Tbird, fun to read your story. Yes, Phuket remains a island in 'honest Thailand'.  It is a reason when I come in with a international flight, I do Immigration at Suvarnabhumi Airport in BKK. There they are more professional, polite and honest, compared with Phuket.  Guess there are more foreigners experience the same. 

Timothy | 28 September 2020 - 08:35:38

Wait a minute....Isn't the hotel the meeting was held at built on the side of a cliff? Isn't it illegal to build on a slope like that? Oh well, never mind. 

ThorFinger | 27 September 2020 - 22:34:32

It seems to be my main comment these days. Well done for speaking openly and honestly. 

Tbird | 27 September 2020 - 22:21:36

I guess I overpaid! When I arrived back in March with an admittedly roughed up looking passport, I was going to be refused entry. Luckily the Officer in charge was a drinking man-I ended up having to hit duty free for a bottle of Johnny Walker Red, and presto....the gates of the Kingdom were opened!

Chas | 27 September 2020 - 14:45:47

Careful, The Phuket News! We don't want you to disappear (or be shunted to the Prime Minister’s Office).

Paddy | 27 September 2020 - 12:01:25

Thank you for your honesty Phuket news. You are the only honest English media outlet for expats in Phuket.

Shwe | 27 September 2020 - 09:34:56

Nice article and very true


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Defence chief denies coup is a possibility

A military coup to oust the military! Hardly likely. Doesn’t the king usually step in? Oh that’s...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: The middle way

DEK,who actually tells you that I am still in LOS ?...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: The middle way

"...lack of brain capacity",haha and this from someone who still can't find a way out ...(Read More)

Phuket Veg Fest food vendors warned of overcharging

Aha. What about keeping this policies also for farang tourists in future? Like for taxis, tuktuks et...(Read More)

Phuket Immigration confirms retirement ‘visa’ income combo still accepted

Most embassies no longer issue letters as they cannot comply with immigration dept requirements, so ...(Read More)

Phuket Veg Fest food vendors warned of overcharging

Very good counter actions against these profiteers. The Vegetarian Festival is a spiritual event not...(Read More)

First group of Chinese visitors arrive

I thought the visit of 120 was cancelled as no one actually applied for it?...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: The middle way are directed to my previous posts in which an explanation to your questions was given, I am...(Read More)

First group of Chinese visitors arrive

This is a good start, but the STV plan will not enable most travel-related shops, restaurants and ho...(Read More)

First group of Chinese visitors arrive

41 tourists or 1,200 STV visits per month cannot quickly solve the current economic and tourism diff...(Read More)