The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Phuket Opinion: Bungling expectations

PHUKET: The palaver this week over face masks still being required in Phuket while in public areas exposed a wide range of bungling from key stakeholders, very few of whom would like to put their hand up and take responsibility.

By The Phuket News

Sunday 5 June 2022, 10:00AM

Tourists on Bangla Rd earlier this week, with no expectation of being forced to wear a face mask. Photo: PR Phuket

Tourists on Bangla Rd earlier this week, with no expectation of being forced to wear a face mask. Photo: PR Phuket

While many people would like to blame local officials for the whole mess, that is not entirely true.

When the order was issued, Thai news media outlets jumped on the news, claiming in very clear language that the face mask rule had been dropped. What ensued was a natural consequence of modern-day copy-and-paste “journalism”, leading to major news outlets erroneously reporting the same thing.

The Phuket News did not have that understanding (see original story by The Phuket News on Wednesday here). The original order did not say that the face mask rule had been dropped. However, it also did not clearly say that the rule remained in effect in general areas. The wording left a gap that allowed for the misunderstanding.

By Thursday, Phuket Governor Narong Woonciew issued a revision to the newly issued face mask order. He did not “reverse” any decision, despite what news outlets later reported. He did not step his bounds by issuing an order not sanctioned by Bangkok, and was not consequently “slapped”.

The revision only clarified what the original order already explained, describing the same rule in clearer language. (See original order posted in Thai here. See revision posted in Thai here.) 

What did not help was the national office of state news agency NNT reporting that the Governor had reversed his decision – something that their local counterparts in the same organisation never reported. Having a state news agency report something that an official never did simply because of the number of other reports by media outlets saying that he did, is simply astounding.

What the Governor, and other local officials, did bungle is how clear information explained in simple terms is essential. This they have failed to learn from the height of the pandemic when new rules were being rolled out every week, and confusion ensued week after week.

What local officials have also failed to learn is how much English-speaking people around the world rely on non-government media to confirm and explain any new rules, as information announced in Thai is so often so confusing that hardly any outsider can make solid sense of it.

The CCSA in Bangkok knows this so well that throughout the pandemic they rightly had their regular reports presented by fluent English-speaking officials. If the information being announced was vague, then at least non-Thai speakers would know that.

Phuket, as a province looking to regain its place as the second-largest contributor to the national economy through tourism, must have clear information relayed in English, as that is the common language used between speakers whose native languages are different.

The Phuket News has for years called for important official announcements affecting foreigners to be made in English – by a fluent English speaker. What we saw this week is what happens when they aren’t.

What local officials also saw this week was the reaction to the news by foreigners. Everyone was expecting the face mask rule to be dropped, just as it has been in many countries around the world where they understand that the main danger of COVID-19 has passed. That didn’t happen. The angry reaction online was the result.

Foreign tourists are waiting for Thailand to catch up and finally “ease” its COVID restrictions to the point where they will be comfortable visiting here. They do not want to travel to a place where they are still living in the COVID world. That is what they want a holiday from.

Just as with the pointless Thailand Pass registration still required, which officials themselves now say are approved “automatically”, any extra bother a tourist needs to deal with to holiday here is just another psychological barrier and a reason to say, “No”.

Thailand needs to remove as many barriers to the decision-making process as possible, especially the rules that no longer make sense.

Perhaps someone should tell this to Prime Minister Prayut Chan-o-cha when he visits Phuket tomorrow (June 6).

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


christysweet | 07 June 2022 - 18:37:56

UK family of four bouncing around the Bang-Tao Lotus " We don't have to wear masks - the rules have changed..." Manager of Lotus; "put on masks".58 

CaptainJack69 | 06 June 2022 - 11:50:32

It's the same reason why so many here resisted mask wearing in the first place. Back when people started wearing them out of fear as a knee jerk reaction to events in China and long before the situation actually warranted it people started making Phuket look dangerous and unappealing as a holiday destination by wearing masks. It was bad then and its still bad now.

Longtimer | 05 June 2022 - 17:18:24

Kakka2 you need to get out of bangla road more often. 100 pct face coverage outside the drinking areas. Ridiculous to say otherwise.

SEC2 | 05 June 2022 - 15:20:17

Good piece. Interesting comments on the psychological barriers in place  and how people want / need a vacation from living in the COVID world. Government needs to think like a tourist, which will never happen I guess.

Kurt | 05 June 2022 - 13:25:06

Great Opinion! Info gaps,  lack of essential info, not standard use of english ( beside thai), still remain hanging in 'full Covid times', including that stupid not sense making Thailand Pass. Total absence of feeling for ínternational tourist thinking.

christysweet | 05 June 2022 - 13:15:08

TPN has always been extremely responsible in NOT cutting & pasting reports and deserves much gratitude for this journalistic integrity.

christysweet | 05 June 2022 - 13:12:13

Meanwhile, hundreds of qualified NES expats  on Phuket could easily proofread and verify announcements and likely would volunteer this as a community service, but nooooooo... can't have the detested 'farang' contributing to society. 

punter | 05 June 2022 - 11:58:40

Exactly John C and what is so funny is that they accept dress codes with no problem yet a mask to prevent illness will never be considered a dress code.

Ash Ward | 05 June 2022 - 11:42:24

On my walk around Patong last night, very few people wearing masks including the locals. 

Kakka2 | 05 June 2022 - 11:34:20

LOL..this is a total joke and this banana governor really like to look like an idiot... no one and i mean no one is using mask in Phuket seens a few month already and look at the picture on this article if any does.. this really show how detached from reality this puppet is.. zero understanding and probably just driven by obscure people behind him...  how many 20K thb fine have been issued so far?

JohnC | 05 June 2022 - 10:27:55

The problem is that most westerners think wearing a mask is taking away what they like to class as their "personal freedoms" while Asians long before the pandemic were comfortable wearing masks for their own personal protection and most are still happy to. If people don't want to follow the rules made for the good of everyone then go somewhere else and pass on your diseases to them i...


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
EXAT Governor in Phuket for B30bn expressway survey

A nice little earner for some. Just destroys some of the last remaining beauty on Phuket driving an ...(Read More)

Expats caught up in Phuket visa scams face being forced to leave the country

That many Expats now get in problems with their visa is due to inyentional unlawful handling of RTP,...(Read More)

Expats caught up in Phuket visa scams face being forced to leave the country

Time Thai Ministry of Justice start investigating RTP station commanders who ignored more than 100 f...(Read More)

PM ’upbeat’ over tourist numbers

Another 'tourist storm' starts up: Dual hotelroom pricing for foreigners! Just announced/sug...(Read More)

EXAT Governor in Phuket for B30bn expressway survey

All those land plots no doubt were bought by HiSos or senior government officials at ridiculously ch...(Read More)

Expats caught up in Phuket visa scams face being forced to leave the country

It's time PM Prayut, foreign minister Don and Embassies take the helm in this scamming and seedy...(Read More)

Phuket Governor addresses tsunami fears

It's all very well saying Phuket is prepared to respond in case of a tsunami warning but how wel...(Read More)

PM ’upbeat’ over tourist numbers

A perfect storm of a global recession , high fuel prices which will flow through to ticket prices on...(Read More)

Expats caught up in Phuket visa scams face being forced to leave the country

Best to get the embassies involved. Spread the word about this scam, which most likely is a "jo...(Read More)