Kata Rocks
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

MaAnn slammed for no lifeguards at Surin Beach, tourists rescued by local surfer

MaAnn slammed for no lifeguards at Surin Beach, tourists rescued by local surfer

PHUKET: MaAnn Samran, Chief of the Cherng Talay Tambon Administration (OrBorTor), today gave no explanation as to why no red flags were posted on Surin Beach yesterday (Sept 1) while he was already aware that there were no lifeguards on duty during dangerous surf conditions that saw at least two tourists rescued by a local surfer.

By The Phuket News

Monday 2 September 2019, 01:31PM

Surin Beach, for years already notorious for its dangerous surf during the southwest monsoon from May through October, was especially dangerous yesterday from the heavy weather that pounded Phuket’s west coast over the weekend.

Waves up to two metres high were dumping on the beach, while deadly rip currents whisked swimmers away from the shore, local surfers and regular beachgoers told The Phuket News.

At about 5pm, a Filipino couple were caught in a rip current, requiring local surfer Danny Hyams to grab a long board and paddle out not once, but twice, to rescue the couple one by one.

The Filipino woman was found several hundred metres offshore by the good Samaritan surfer. Witnesses say the woman was in poor condition and she was rushed to hospital by ambulance.

Mr MaAnn told The Phuket News that he knew about the two tourists needing to be rescued by a local beachgoer, but was unable to give any description of their current physical condition.

He also gave no explanation why red flags that had already been posted along the beach had been removed, even though he knew there were no lifeguards on duty.

Instead, Mr Ma Ann today said he wanted to warn tourists that swimming at Surin Beach is dangerous.

“Please do not go into the water at Surin Beach until there are yellow-red flags posted on the beach,” he said.

The Phuket News confirmed that as of this morning there were no yellow-red ‘Safe Swim Zone” flags posted anywhere along Surin Beach.

“There are red flags clearly posted along on Surin Beach. Please don’t go into the water with bad weather like this,” Mr MaAnn said.

“Today, I have added (sic) 12 more red flags, which are marked ‘Do Not Swim’ in Thai and English language. I think, they are good enough for tourists to understand them,” he added.

The red flags have been posted high, about 1.8 to two metres, Mr MaAnn said.

However, again in contrast, photos provided to The Phuket News showed only plain red flags with no written warnings on them posted on tall sticks planted along the shore.

Mr MaAnn this morning, angered for being questioned, went at lengths to explain that there were no lifeguards on the beach yesterday – and today, and for the foreseeable future – because he had no choice due to decisions made beyond his control.

“There is an internal management issue which concerning the Comptroller General’s Department (CGD),” he said.


“The CGD opinion is to agree for LP Laikhum to provide lifeguards on Surin Beach (under a local council project funded) by Cherng Talay OrBorTor.

“I have presented issue to ask the opinion of officials at Phuket Provincial Office (headed by Phuket Governor Phakaphong Tavipatana), and they agree for LP Laikhum to be hired (to provide lifeguards,” Mr MaAnn said.

“I have sent an official reminder to LP Laikhum to work (sic) at Surin Beach. If they are not ready to work, I will continue to hire the previous lifeguard team (see story here),” he added.

“But I must wait for LP Laikhum to reply to me within one week,” Mr MaAnn said.

Mr MaAnn initially agreed to give The Phuket News contact information for “lifeguards”, but did not clarify whether the contact information would be for LP Laikhum or the lifeguards who patrolled beach last month.

Mr MaAnn called back later to retract the offer to allow The Phuket News access to confirm his version of events.

Meanwhile, International Surf Lifesaving Association (ISLA) Marine Safety Officer Daren Jenner delivered serious comments on the failure of Cherng Talay OrBorTor to provide lifeguards at Surin Beach – and the removal of red flags warning tourists it is not safe to enter the water.

“The ISLA condemns the acts of any public official who knowingly or willfully removes lifeguard services when lives are at stake. This incident is much more than a coincidence and should be investigated to the full extent of the law,” Mr Jenner said.

“In this case, it placed the lives of both victims and the humanitarian rescuer at stake,” he added.

The need to rescue the two Filipino tourists came as one Chinese tourist was swept into the sea south of Patong yesterday at Freedom Beach*, where no lifeguards on patrol.

The search for the tourist, Yin Lei, 35, from Henan, resumed this morning. (See story here.)

It also followed lifeguards at Patong Beach “closing” the beach to swimmers on Friday as surf conditions were too dangerous. (See story here.)

Lifeguards re-opened “safe swimming zones” marked with yellow-red flags along Patong Beach on Saturday, but with a stern warning from Patong Surf Life Saving Chief Somprasong Sangchart for people to obey lifeguards’ instructions and to obey the red “No Swimming” flags for their own safety. (See story here.)

Regardless, the rescues continued at Patong over the weekend with at least eight people rescued on Saturday and another three tourists – one Chinese, one Middle Eastern and one European – all requiring oxygen breathing assistance once brought safely back to shore to recover from exhaustion. (See video here.)

* CORRECTION: Not Tri Trang Beach, as initially reported. The error is sincerely regretted.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Kurt | 04 September 2019 - 11:18:21

In one word,... Phuket Officialdom does not provide beach safety in a way that lost of tourist life can be prevented. Untrained, ignorant life guards ( iPhone concentration in the shadow), law wise not equipped to forbid ignorant tourists to enter the water at dangerous times.  For smoking and drinking are strict beach rules. Why not for entering water during dangerous times??

GregoryJCS | 04 September 2019 - 09:02:16

Nothing new about this. We surfers have been saving tourists and locals for as long as I have been here  (25 years) and will continue to do so when the lifeguards are not able or capable, or just not there cause they are too bury playing with their smartphones or chatting up tourist girls. True, see it all the time.

Christy Sweet | 04 September 2019 - 00:28:37

Am I mistaken, that due to the last coup d'etat, there hasn't been an election for Or Bor Tor Chief in some  years?

Kurt | 03 September 2019 - 11:23:08

Is it not possible to transfer mr MaAnn to a small inland village were he can do no harm by his passiveness in beach and environment matters? His village head network in Cherng Talay and around it seems not to work in matters of environment and beach safety. When the Government will look into his dysfunctional being?

Fascinated | 02 September 2019 - 23:18:55

The man is an absolute disgrace and no contrition whatsoever when things bite him in the backside, It's always 'bigger boys did it' or 'not my responsibility or 'I must wait for........'.  Nothing in it for him I guess so he's not interested.

Foot | 02 September 2019 - 16:31:37

All according to plan.
Tourists not wanted or encouraged to visit.
What makes anyone think otherwise?

Sir Burr | 02 September 2019 - 15:23:17

He's still there because of the voters of Surin. I'll let you guess how he keeps them.

BenPendejo | 02 September 2019 - 14:31:37

This should be the last straw for Mr. Ma-an. At best, his inaction represents dereliction of duty, at worst, criminal negligence of a public official. The people throughout his jurisdiction deserve better, and most have had enough of his  ongoing disregard for public safety, the environment, and for quality of life in general. Time for the Governor to step up for a change and !DO SOMETHING!

Kurt | 02 September 2019 - 13:47:12

How much longer tolerate the Phuket Governor, and if he is not willing to take steps, the BKK Government a Village Head as mr MaAnn? 'His' Surin park thing not worked out, the beach and community environment scandals.'No control'. His district is a shame. How long the world can read negatively about this man?
What is powering him to remain Village head?  Money? Bad Phuket image co...

Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Phuket Opinion: This cannot be tolerated

Children used to sell flowers is a common sight in many towns throughout many towns in Thailand. I&#...(Read More)

Royal rainmakers halt Phuket cloud-seeding operations

Of course they take credit, for making it rain, but there's no eay to prove it.... me thinks it ...(Read More)

Phuket Property Guide: Bungalows and villas

It is NEVER safe to purchase anything in thailand because Thai judiciary cannot protect you against ...(Read More)

Thai resort prices starting to squeeze Europeans

...specially for children. Many foreigners, previous repeaters. turn their back to Thailand. It...(Read More)

Thai resort prices starting to squeeze Europeans

Well, marketing, with a international scope is not what thai do. It is all,...'this is the way w...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: This cannot be tolerated

It is time Phuket gets a statue showing that children in torn, dirty clothes selling things late ev...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: This cannot be tolerated

Great piece of Opinion! Doesn't need any comment. Phuket top Officials should bow their heads i...(Read More)

Man found dead in smoke-filled pickup, wife believes depression led to suicide

Strange. Why the woman didn't pull husband out of the car and tried CPR until rescue workers arr...(Read More)

Army hunts Yala checkpoint attackers

Intelligence of the 4th Army failed terrible ( Or?). ...."This village never before considerat...(Read More)

Krathong girl makes thousands on floats

All these thai rubber laws, pfff. Thai use any law if it is convenient ( read: when it is profitabl...(Read More)