The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Hospital faces police probe over baby’s broken arm

Hospital faces police probe over baby’s broken arm

PHUKET: The parents of the newborn girl who suffered a broken arm while in care at Vachira Phuket Hospital have filed a formal complaint with police to pursue charges.

By Eakkapop Thongtub

Saturday 11 June 2022, 02:48PM

Photo: Eakkapop Thongtub

Photo: Eakkapop Thongtub

The parents, mother Atchara Chantrat and father Chakkrit Nimnoo, filed the formal complaint at Phuket City police Station yesterday (June 10).

Lt Col Ying Chittiwa Thanavitwilas, Deputy Chief of Investigation at Phuket City Police, received the complaint.

Mr Chakkrit explained that only a statement of the incident was entered into the daily record at Phuket City Police on Tuesday (June 7), asking for the hospital to answer their requests for an explanation as to how their daughter’s arm was broken. It was not a formal complaint, he said.

The formal complaint filed yesterday followed Vachira Phuket Hospital Director Dr Weerasak Lorthongkham, joined by a team of doctors and nurses, holding a press conference at the hospital on Wednesday ‒ after the parents brought the matter to the attention of the police.

Dr Weerasak apologised for the incident and explained that the breaking of the newborn’s arm was likely due to the way the baby had been swaddled, with handling of the baby in accordance with standard procedures likely leading to the breaking of the arm.

However, Dr Weerasak did not admit any responsibility of the hospital for the injury to the infant, and did not name any person responsible for the broken arm.

Internal - Phuket News TV

Mr Chakkrit yesterday said he and Ms Atchara were not satisfied with the hospital’s response.

“The hospital is taking responsibility only for the cost of treatment [for the broken arm], but no responsibility for the person responsible. We do not know who that person is yet, so we decided to file a complaint for breaking the law,” he said.

“The hospital has set up a committee to investigate this matter, but has not specified a date for announcing the results [of the investigation]. Therefore, outside agencies, such as the police, Ombudsman’s Office and the media among others are encouraged to come and help check on this as well,” he added.

“Right now we are stressed and worried about our daughter. Will the broken arm present difficulties later in the future? Will it return to the way it was before? Because when she was born, everything was normal.

“We would like to know the results of the hospital’s work on who broke the child’s arm. Therefore came to file this complaint to encourage Vachira Phuket Hospital to work faster, because it feels like the hospital is hiding something and we have no confidence in the hospital,” Mr Chakkrit said.

“We must agree that she [his daughter] receives full treatment for her arm, but I really hope this is the last time we deal with the hospital. I want the person responsible to be accountable according to the law,” he said.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Kurt | 12 June 2022 - 12:13:00

The more twisting nonsense the Vachira medici try to sell to the public, the more they make their incompetence and untruthfulness visible to the public. Conforming Vachira's reputation.

JohnC | 12 June 2022 - 08:35:07

[..standard procedures likely leading to the breaking of the arm] What standard procedures? In this country that can mean anything but most often is used for an excuse when those responsible try to cover their arses. Change hospital, the reputation, (or lack of),  of Wachira is very well documented.

christysweet | 11 June 2022 - 22:21:59

Babies have very soft and pliable bones and it takes quite a bit of force to break a bone in them. Yes investigate and  question all  who were ever in the  same room as the infant because abuse is a possibility. 


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Phuket Governor addresses tsunami fears

Given that he is such a clever airport damage engineer and road flooding engineer.Maybe get out and ...(Read More)

Expats caught up in Phuket visa scams face being forced to leave the country

This highlights a obvious flaw in the current system, what happens if you lose your passport. Emerge...(Read More)

Chinese investors courted

Is anyone keeping count of the hubs- its off the scale. Just another vassal state for the future. Ju...(Read More)

Crew rescued as cargo boat sinks in storm

I wonder if the alleged millions of baht worth of cargo was insured?...(Read More)

Expats caught up in Phuket visa scams face being forced to leave the country

" No mercy for Expats" is the sett up of Immigration and their Agents friends. Their aim i...(Read More)

Expats caught up in Phuket visa scams face being forced to leave the country

Expats caught in visa scam of 2 Agents and Phuket Immigration being forced to leave the country, eve...(Read More)

Officials assure Phuket is prepared for tsunami warning

DDPM-Phuket Chief talks 'keep calm' nonsense. Telling Phuket- (and Phang Nga) people that P...(Read More)

Expats caught up in Phuket visa scams face being forced to leave the country

And off course the NACC Phuket Chief Suksan Prasara-ae are silent. ...(Read More)

Expats caught up in Phuket visa scams face being forced to leave the country

This is a criminal violation and in no way under the jurisdiction of Immigration. Use of an agent ...(Read More)