Scott Robertson oversaw 20 victories during his tenure as coach of the team from 27 matches. That’s an impressive 74% win ratio, which is more than his predecessor.
However, New Zealand Rugby chair David Kirk said it was the right time to make a change and Robertson was therefore released last Thursday (Jan 15).
Despite impressive results, it wasn’t all plain sailing under Robertson. Liam MacDonald was the first assistant coach to leave, citing differences in attacking policy. Forwards coach Clayton McMillan was soon to follow, preferring a head coach role at Munster.
This was the first sign that there may be a man-management issue. Coaching is a competitive arena, even within your own coaching group. If, as a head coach, you have talented and proven assistants, you must allow them to work freely under agreed guidelines.
So, who started the rot? Was it player-driven? Ardea Savea’s name is prominent. Scott Barrett is now recognised as a poor selection as captain. Did the players complain about Robertson’s coaching style through Barrett? Who are the coaching contenders? The captain/coach relationship will be fundamental in restoring playing standards ahead of a 4-test tour of South Africa in August and September. The winner of which will take series levels of confidence into the 2027 World Cup.
Jamie Joseph and Ardea Savea are said to have a healthy respect for each other. Joe Schmidt resigned from the Wallabies coaching position a year before the World Cup in Australia. Why would he do that? Pat Lam is currently coaching at the Bristol Bears in the Gallagher Premiership. He is regarded as a player’s coach, and his teams play attractive rugby.
As for ‘Razor’ Robertson. His contract bars him from taking another top international job for the next 12 months. Many clubs would welcome his presence and experience throughout Europe.
What do I think? I remember watching the All Blacks play in England in the 70s. They were a relentless machine, always driving forward and supporting hard. I think that is what’s missing in All Black play currently. The old school that lurks in the shadows feed off those years and wants them back and quickly!
My tip is a Joseph/Savea combination for at least 2 years.
Wherever you live, enjoy your rugby.
The Global Rugby Coach, Mike Penistone, is a globally renowned professional rugby coach based in Phuket who is also an ambassador for the Asia Center Foundation, a charity for disadvantaged children. For more information visit: www.rugbycoachingconsultancy.com.