The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Phuket Opinion: For stupidity, click repeat

Phuket Opinion: For stupidity, click repeat

PHUKET: The Navy’s action to file a criminal complaint against American Chad Elwartowski and his Thai partner Supranee Thepdet for the “seastead” built in the waters some 42 kilometres south of Phuket is sadly laughable, but should come as no surprise.

By The Phuket News

Sunday 21 April 2019, 09:00AM

A Royal Thai Navy ship holds at a distance from the ’seastead’ south of Phuket. Photo: Royal Thai Navy

A Royal Thai Navy ship holds at a distance from the ’seastead’ south of Phuket. Photo: Royal Thai Navy

On learning of the charge, the couple went into hiding, reportedly fearful for their safety. That may sound ludicrous, but the couple were facing a charge under Section 119 of the Criminal Code, and that section is no laughing matter.

The section concerns any acts that cause the country or parts of it to fall under the sovereignty of a foreign state or deterioration of the state’s independence. The law is parked in the same section of the Criminal Code as lese majeste, which is only a few paragraphs earlier as Section 112.

Unlike lese majeste, which incurs a punishment of three to 15 years’ imprisonment if found guilty, breach of Section 119 is punishable by death or life imprisonment.

No one would believe that the Navy officials involved in the seastead case are actually pursuing that level of punishment. They were just looking for the legal right to have the structure removed. Did they make this clear to the public? No, they did not. And that is where they failed to understand the use of the law.

If their intent was simply to have the seastead removed, they missed the goal by a mile. All the Navy had to do was point to Thailand as a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). A quick read of the first few pages reveals that signatory nations may claim a straight line between outlying islands of the country as included in the “12 mile” definition of territorial waters.

Did they first discuss the issue with the builders and ask for the structure to be removed? No, they did not, despite talks being the standard first step for anyone found encroaching on protected forest or even national park land, a practice that the Navy itself has had plenty of, well, practice, in on this very island.

Instead, we saw heavy-handed, unilateral decision-making at its finest. If you want to create a climate of fear, this is what you get.

tile-it - Phuket’s Quality Tile Boutique

Now compare this to handling of the forest hillside in Chiang Mai raped to make way for an “accommodation development” literally one year ago – and even the generals in Bangkok backed down on that one. The accommodation, built on the foothills of one of the best-known national parks in the country, was allowed to stay. Apparently, even for the top brass, it would be difficult to win a court case against the very judges deciding it.

Instead, the project is now to be used for “public benefit”, said Deputy PM Gen Prawit Wongsuwan in delivering the news to the press. “Perhaps as a vacation spot,” he said. Indeed.

The seastead debacle also came at the end of the same week that Phuket’s “image” suffered from ridiculous headlines in the international media – including among respected publications – of the death penalty for taking selfies on the beach near the end of the runway.

By the time airport management figured out it was best to denounce the stories it was too late. The news had spread like a virus.

Considering all the hyperbole about preserving Phuket’s image as an international tourism destination, you’d have thought that the key players on the island would have learned this one by now. Step up, be rational, speak your intent clearly and do it. Apparently not.

But one thing that has surfaced from the seastead farce: a whole new form of tourism accommodation that remains an unexplored segment in holiday properties. One has to wonder if any noses are out of joint that they didn’t think of it – or get to it – first.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Kurt | 21 April 2019 - 14:51:13

Clear Opinion piece!  Well, the navy has nothing to do,they are happy to make from a mouse a 'massaged elephant'. How com royal thai navy didn't noticed the transport of seastead from thai ship yard to present anchor location?
Now, out of the blue it is a national security threat, + many more threats. Thai navy soap drama optima forma, to cover it selves being passive

Shwe | 21 April 2019 - 11:49:26

"But one thing that has surfaced from the seastead farce: a whole new form of tourism accommodation that remains an unexplored segment in holiday properties. One has to wonder if any noses are out of joint that they didn’t think of it – or get to it – first" you hit the nail on the head there, big money at risk if hotels can be set up without having to report anything


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
CCSA fears infections surge over long weekend

'No new cases' is just propaganda. They hardly test local people. Among all tested returnin...(Read More)

Chinese tourists for Phuket ‘bubble’

Has Bangkok forgotten already, where that virus came from . Mr. Happy is in China's pocket....(Read More)

Sustainably Yours: Solving Phuket’s Water Crisis

All good points and completely true. But Thai's don't do anything unless they're forced ...(Read More)

Nightlife to resume, some foreigners allowed in

The height of sexism to criminalize women's breasts, which are identical to overweight males...(Read More)

TAT Governor marks more than 100 Phuket tourism operators awarded SHA certification

When I, as a 'quality tourist' would arrive in a ***** Thai hotel and see that SHA sticker, ...(Read More)

CCSA fears infections surge over long weekend

Well, with Thailand in a actually in a insular 'lock down' to the outside world. ( beside b...(Read More)

EU opens borders to ‘safe’ countries including Thailand

EU put graciously Thailand on the list of countries who might visit EU countries. Now Thailand has t...(Read More)

Chinese tourists for Phuket ‘bubble’

quality tourist from Europe will not be coming if the Chinese are in Phuket, who wants to risk being...(Read More)

Chinese tourists for Phuket ‘bubble’

I miss Thai Government stand how China publicly , till now handle their Hunan- and Swine virus outbr...(Read More)

Phuket bar rules revealed, operators warned to comply or face closure

Must close at midnight, Right. Where were all the health Officials, police, Patong Mayor, mr Sirawat...(Read More)