BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search


Phuket Opinion: Behind closed doors

Phuket Opinion: Behind closed doors

PHUKET: The recent police raid on a sex orgy at a hotel in Pattaya has accidentally highlighted a critical issue with sloppy Thai lawmaking. Specifically in the Pattaya case, the question is exactly which laws were broken?

sexcrimepolicetourism
By The Phuket News

Sunday 29 April 2018, 09:00AM


The party goers were rounded up by security authorities on April 21 at a hotel in Pattaya where they attended a swingers’ party. Photo: Chaiyot Pupattanapong

The party goers were rounded up by security authorities on April 21 at a hotel in Pattaya where they attended a swingers’ party. Photo: Chaiyot Pupattanapong

Profiting from sex in Thailand is illegal, as is receiving any benefit from the proceeds of prostitution. Bar owners take note.

But in this instance, all police can prove so far is that people paid B1,500 per head to join the party. If that money simply paid for the venue, drinks and food (and who is to say that it wasn’t?), then any sex that took place was “not for profit” as it were – just as it is with normal couples.

So under these circumstances if these people are guilty of Thailand’s sex laws, then so are everyone else, even married couples who enjoy a weekend away to rekindle their romance – a fact that gives s light chuckle towards the government promoting honeymoon holidays to the Land of Smiles.

People may or may not agree with it, but unless harm is done such activities behind closed doors are a private affair between consenting adults. And on this issue, trying to leverage prostitution laws to regulate what is nothing more than an “adult-entertainment event”, would be hilarious if it weren’t for the existence of Thailand’s notorious sex-tourism destinations such as Patong and Pattaya.

Thai Residential

On that note, the current attack on Thailand and its thriving sex industry is confusing many issues, including inferences of human trafficking and child sex slavery while only mentioning “sex tours” during which tourists engage with prostitutes (see here). The two are not the same. To wit, all eastern states in Australia have fully legalised prostitution while the rest of the states have made independent sex work legal, but kept brothels illegal. The UK has yet to catch up, but advocates are hoping that a landmark case currently being heard in the High Court might change that.

However, worse for the Pattaya case is that the General Manager of the hotel is facing charges of providing a venue for the activity, and reports of some B18 million in fines in the air. In this, GMs in Phuket should be shaking in their boots considering that the understanding of the law just shown in Pattaya delivers Phuket’s keen honeymoon holiday market a swift kick between the legs.

Cases such as this demonstrate how laws are picked up and used willy-nilly by law-enforcers. This is often aided by the fact that most laws in Thailand are so vaguely worded they allow for idiotically wide interpretation by those enforcing it. Bad laws encourage bad enforcement. The law cannot vaguely say “you know what I mean” and leave police to do the rest. The raid in Pattaya may look official, but a simple shakedown by cops is no different.

As for the Pattaya raid, whether it was motivated by a sense of moral outrage or simply to make a quick buck, it was not lawful – and only serves to reinforce one of the root causes of corruption in Thailand.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

CAPTCHA

Crusader79 | 30 April 2018 - 08:22:43

I don't know, seems if there's any case in which the laws should be used willy-nilly it's this one...:-) 

CaptainJack69 | 29 April 2018 - 11:25:55

Same with the raid on a "gay sauna" in Bangkok the week before. What consenting adults choose to do at a private venue is their own business, regardless of who they offend or who they neglect to pay off. In that case no sex acts could even be proven and the police left empty handed.

As many pragmatists say "There's no such thing as free sex" does that make it prostitutio...

Kurt | 29 April 2018 - 09:59:10

Bravo! Great piece of Opinion.

Yes, the Pattaya police raid was hilarious One can't make it up.
Motivated by a sense of moral outrage??  In Pattaya, by RTP ?? LOL 
Of course it was a quick 'professional' big buck matter.

Pattaya police of the City of Sins likes it sometimes to attract attention in a funny way, like arresting pensioner bridge or dart players. 
Key factor? Money...

Discover Thainess | 29 April 2018 - 09:52:09

The other issue is the moral bandwagon that everyone jumps on saying how this party was outrageous and damaging to Thailand’s image, but of course if the raid had not been carried out, or the details of the raid not been paraded in front of the media, no one would ever have known. Therefore any damage has been caused by the media parade, not by the party!

 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
No need for COVID-19 test to extend visa, says Phuket Immigration

@tamvong yes, there have been changes through these trying times, but at the end of the day, the aut...(Read More)


No need for COVID-19 test to extend visa, says Phuket Immigration

Thank you very much for the quick clarification, Deputy Chief Col Nareuwat Putthawiro. I hear the ru...(Read More)


Phuket international school dodges charges for illegally hiring British teachers

@Fascinated "... they are part of the problem" Yeah , and your hue and cry will probabl...(Read More)


Don’t worry about air quality, says Phuket health office

I know just what Kurt means when he says it is a massage people article. He was hoping that it would...(Read More)


Struck poor by COVID, Phuket man tries to sell eye on Facebook

Good thing he didn't sell one of his eyes, as I'm sure he would have got his job back as a b...(Read More)


No need for COVID-19 test to extend visa, says Phuket Immigration

There's all this talk about "red zones" and self quarantine and reporting to local med...(Read More)


No need for COVID-19 test to extend visa, says Phuket Immigration

Wait for them to change their minds in 10, 9, 8, 7.........(Read More)


Man slain in Phuket car park over ‘personal dispute’

Sadly I will have to agree with PR. This is premeditated murder...(Read More)


Phuket tackles overpriced taxi fares for tourists

Is this story on a loop. Sounds like ground hog day again....(Read More)