The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Phuket Opinion: A uniformed response

Phuket Opinion: A uniformed response

PHUKET: The Royal Thai Navy Third Area Command, based in Phuket, issued a press release on Friday (Sept 11) that was more than a little disconcerting. The press release espoused how our good Navy was doing its part in protecting the country from illegal immigrants arriving from Myanmar, under the guise that it was protecting local people from illegal arrivals who may be bringing the COVID-19 virus with them.

By The Phuket News

Sunday 13 September 2020, 09:00AM

Personnel at the Royal Thai Navy Third Area Command monitor satellite and drone footage from a Navy control room. Photo: Royal Thai Navy / Third Area Command

Personnel at the Royal Thai Navy Third Area Command monitor satellite and drone footage from a Navy control room. Photo: Royal Thai Navy / Third Area Command

The Navy release explained how Admiral Sittiporn Maskasem, Chief of Naval Operations, had come to Phuket in person to review the action being taken by the Third Area Command.

Of course, the response was that the personnel at the Phuket naval base, which is responsible for all naval action along Thailand entire Andaman coast, was on watch for these potentially dangerous migrants through various means, including its UAV drone and by “working with” officials in Ranong, the province north of Phuket which directly shares its water borders with Myanmar.

What was not included in the press release was any steps to help prevent COVID-19 from being brought onto the island by road, despite Phang Nga, the province immediately north of Phuket, reimposing strict health measures a week ago amid fears that migrant workers from Myanmar being brought into the province illegally by employers. 

Now that is much closer to the truth, and those heightened COVID-prevention measures were doled out by Phang Nga Governor Chamroen Tipayapongtada, a relatively young Governor who was very well liked during his term as Governor of Phuket only a handful of years ago.

Governor Chamroen knows how the local ‘migrant worker import’ system works so well that he warned all officials and employers they would face legal action for any infected migrant workers found in the respective areas.

Meanwhile, Phuket Provincial Police and provincial government officials have yet to announce any steps to check any persons, including migrant workers, arriving in Phuket by road. If these migrant workers bringing COVID-19 to Phuket were such a genuine concern, our officials forgot to stop and check people at the bridge.

Much, much worse, however, is how the phrase “illegal immigrants from Myanmar” was applied. The release came just four days after nearly 300 more Rohingya made landfall in Aceh, at the northern tip of Sumatra – just 200km southwest of Phuket.

The 297 refugees comprised 181 men and women, and 14 children. They were reportedly at sea for six months, and made land on Sumatra amid the dangerous southwest monsoon conditions.

Thai Residential

Chris Lewa, director of the Arakan Project, a non-profit group focusing on the Rohingya crisis, said the passengers that arrived in Aceh on Monday had set sail from southern Bangladesh at the end of March or early April, bound for Malaysia.

It was also confirmed that the Royal Thai Navy was continuing its “push back” policy of intercepting refugee boats at sea to prevent them from coming ashore in Thailand.

The Royal Thai Navy – and the Thai media – have made no mention of this policy for years. Even after the great fiasco where the Royal Thai Navy was exposed for its active role in preventing refugees from arriving in Thailand, it called the process “helping them on”.

If they think they doing the right thing by this, they can think again. This “helping them on” just further endangers these refugees in poorly maintained boats on dangerous seas, and has led to boat sinkings and drownings further south beyond the Thai Navy’s “area of responsibility”. In July Malaysian authorities said some two dozen Rohingya migrants feared to have drowned off the country’s coast after a treacherous boat crossing had been found alive, hiding in bushes on an island. They were the lucky ones.

For those with short memories, the “push back” policy began years ago with Army Commander Lt Gen Manas Kongpan, who was the Internal Security Operations Command (Isoc) Region 4 Commander at the time.

He has now been sentenced to 82 years in jail for his role in human trafficking following the discovery of diabolical mass graves found at makeshift prisons in the jungle near the Mayalsian boarder in Padang Besar, Songkhla province.

If the Royal Thai Navy wants to issue press releases about the “good work” it is doing in “protecting the people of Thailand”, a little more honesty would be appreciated.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Pascale | 14 September 2020 - 15:33:00

@Kurt . Countries like Italy  or Greece will be happy to hear that they have to welcome every boat with refugees now,unless they want to face trial in The Hague for an international crime. Locals on Lesbos etc. will be happy too ! Maybe they should build a refugee camp right next to your house.You could support them daily !

Kurt | 14 September 2020 - 09:51:15

Pascal should study the difference between just border closings and not rescuing open boat refugees  in territorial- and international waters and bring them safe on land.. The last is a international crime.

Dicko | 13 September 2020 - 16:58:14

And somewhat suspiciously we are still seeing visitors from Thailand, having tested negative for coronavirus in Thailand, arriving in other countries and being found to be infected with the virus (3 more in Japan just this week). Really makes you wonder just how many people are really infected in Thailand... 

Pascale | 13 September 2020 - 16:50:36

Kurt, the court of justice in The Hague would be quite busy if every country,who (rightfully)did not allow so called refugees in ,would have to go on trial.Maybe you should recommend your own country to take all refugees in and to take care them very well.Probably your fellow countrymen will be very happy to do so.

Kurt | 13 September 2020 - 11:20:21

On 8 Sept I already wrote: 'Perhaps time to intensify health checks at Sarasin Bridge'  (Article...Border area on high alert, etc). 

Kurt | 13 September 2020 - 11:06:22

Good piece of 'Opinion', in which PN draws attention to the International crimes of the Thai Navy to "push refugee boats back at sea, helping them on". Thai people responsible for this crimes should be black listed and arrested when they show up abroad and brought to International Court of Justice in The Hague to be trialed for crimes against Humanity.


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Police prepare for 3 days of anti-government protests

As long the Government ( Cabinet & rubber stamp Parliament) not make a move to compromise with t...(Read More)

Phuket volunteers wanted to help return captive gibbons to the wild

So I take you are against most visible environmental organization in the world as well...Greenpeace,...(Read More)

Phuket officials look to install animal shelters at all municipalities

To tackle negative reactions of the team of my 'followers' on forehand: In many countries d...(Read More)

‘New Normal’ doubles cost of Phuket election

Jor12,..'the live of people or money'..? At a bit drama tour you are now? Officialdom didn&...(Read More)

Phuket officials look to install animal shelters at all municipalities

Since many months Phuket is not a tourist destination. These problems could have been fixed already....(Read More)

Go home and vote, or lose some civic rights, warns Phuket election office

A lot of forms will be submitted this year. Reasons? 1: I have no job my financial status not allow ...(Read More)

Phuket volunteers wanted to help return captive gibbons to the wild

Ah yes, and bring your own food please as well. Better to visit a Zoo in Europe instead....(Read More)

Phuket volunteers wanted to help return captive gibbons to the wild

So you basically need to pay 2500 THB and work for free 2 till 3 days 6 hours each day. Despite the ...(Read More)

Phuket officials look to install animal shelters at all municipalities

The Phuket authorities have never provided sufficient funds to run the place which is little more th...(Read More)

Phuket volunteers wanted to help return captive gibbons to the wild

K...oh really. What did this mean? "What about Phuket Government contribution?"...(Read More)