333 at the beach Pro Property Partners British International School, Phuket
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Phuket Opinion: A semblance of reassurance

PHUKET: It’s amazing what officials can forget even when they are doing an outstanding job trying to explain an incident when they genuinely have no idea what caused it.

By The Phuket News

Sunday 30 April 2023, 09:00AM

Local DDPM officers pose for a photo with tourists beside the tsunami warning tower at Kamala at 7pm Thursday (Apr 27), more than 15 hours after the siren sounded. Photo: PR Phuket

Local DDPM officers pose for a photo with tourists beside the tsunami warning tower at Kamala at 7pm Thursday (Apr 27), more than 15 hours after the siren sounded. Photo: PR Phuket

The Department of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation Office (DDPM) got nearly everything right in their response to the false alarm issued by three tsunami warning towers in Phuket earlier this week.

Local officials were explaining to the public what had happened in the early morning news, and a full explanation of what was being done had been posted by the national DDPM branch by 3:21pm that day.

The full explanation omitted nothing. Initial inspections of the towers had already indicated that the problem was not local, and the towers were fully inspected and checked by technicians the next day. The fact that 25 disaster warning towers in 14 provinces, including five in Chon Buri as well as one each in widely separated provinces such as Nakhon Sri Thammarat, Nong Bua Lam Phu and even Chiang Rai – was testament to the fact the the problem was somewhere in the national system.

The DDPM explained that the system for issuing disaster warnings from the National Disaster Warning Center is a “double encrypted system”, and it takes an officer to actually press a button to get any towers to sound any sirens. No officer had not sent any signals to any towers to sound their sirens. The problem so far is considered an anomaly, and is being treated seriously.

The DDPM was honest in its message to the public; they had no idea what had caused the malfunction. Literally calling the cause as an “unknown reason”, they even explained their next steps in their continuing investigations in the hope of determining the cause.

Compared with how some Thai government agencies respond publicly to critical issues, the response by the DDPM so far has been first class.

Pro Property Partners

What was not handled so well was the repeated message of the importance of informing tourists of what had happened to inspire confidence in their safety. For that to happen tourists must be informed by the relevant authority in clear English, or other native tongue. Tourists do not speak Thai.

In the heat of the moment, at 3:43am Thursday (Apr 27), the most reassuring factor any tourists would have been presented with was the fact that the hotel staff were still standing in front of them, and not running for the nearest hill.

Local officials going on Thai radio to explain what had happened only means that the tourists will get the message second or third hand. By the time the news cycle finally got the news out to non-Thai speakers, the issue was of image damage control, not safety.

The only other factor overlooked by all officials in responding to the false alarm was that while they were calling on people to not panic, they did not say exactly what people should do if the warning towers sound their alarm again.

The obvious answer is to treat all warnings as such, and take immediate appropriate action, namely evacuate risk areas as quickly as safely possible. But those words were never mentioned, in spoken or written reports. As simple as it is, this is a must if anyone is to try to instill confidence in our tsunami warning system.

In the meantime, the best warning any non-Thai-speaking person will have is to pay attention to what local people are doing, and do the same.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

* (Not Hotmail/Outlook)

Kurt | 02 May 2023 - 09:08:33

Thank you, Mr Herman1. Was a typo.

Hermann1 | 01 May 2023 - 19:19:23

A small reminder for Mr.Kurt and JohnC : The devastating Tsunami happened in 2004  and not in 2014. Just saying.

Kamala Pete | 01 May 2023 - 12:40:22

The exact position and altitude of the warning buoys is measured by GPS satellites being "corrected" by a special (american) satellite, which recently broke down. This seems the most likely cause. Its reassuring that the ground-based components  of the overall system responded quickly and correctly.

JohnC | 01 May 2023 - 08:43:28

The best warning system for telling us a tsunami was coming in 2014 were the Japanese tourists who saw the water going out and started running off the beaches heading inland as fast as they could. Most other nationalities caught on very quickly, except Thais who went towards the water trying to catch stranded fish instead. TIT!

Kurt | 30 April 2023 - 09:49:38

...because: 'no wind, no rain, the sea is calm'. Remember few years ago a alarm?  Many Patong people run for the hills, stay there a whole night. Since than many of them take 'sound warnings' not serious anymore. Most young people in west coast areas have no memory at all of what 2014 tsunami was. Photo posing, funny. What work were the 5+1 doing down that tower at 7pm?

Kurt | 30 April 2023 - 09:35:40

It is clear that on Phuket people, thai- and non thai speaking can't trust the Tsunami warning system. To many times since the system started operation there are failures. Are it not the buoys in the ocean, than it are the alarm towers. Sure there is during weekends/nights/public holidays a man on 'button duty'? Don't be surprised if they go home because: 'no wind, no rain and ...


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Accused Jimi ’Slice’ killer extradited from Canada for slaying in Phuket

40 people plus the aircrew to bring back one man- I bet they were brimming with DutyFree on the way ...(Read More)

MP-elect Somchart calls for buses to serve tourist areas

the airport bus service along the West Coast has proved its worht and their ability to do the job. t...(Read More)

MP-elect Somchart calls for buses to serve tourist areas

Not only are buses a more efficient way to move more people, it also lessens the stranglehold the PL...(Read More)

Further crackdown on illegal foreigners underway

And here comes, Pascale, checking in from his barstool to comment on commenters. Very surprising... ...(Read More)

Russian tourist drowns at Patong Beach

@Kamala Pete - Phuket, like Oz, US and Hawaii, are heavily reliant on tourism and care about tourist...(Read More)

Russian tourist drowns at Patong Beach

@ Kamala Pete, by stating that the beaches here are "fairly safe" shows you don't know...(Read More)

MP-elect Somchart calls for buses to serve tourist areas

At last,buses,light railway,from patong, to karon to kata to nai harn to rawai beach to chalong to p...(Read More)

Russian tourist drowns at Patong Beach

A report about the same incident in Thaiger suggests he was swimming km’s off shore so seems he wa...(Read More)

MP-elect Somchart calls for buses to serve tourist areas

I like this guy more and more a breath of fresh air - scheduled buses will keep tourists off motorbi...(Read More)

MP-elect Somchart calls for buses to serve tourist areas

Yep yep, now first time ever I think that green stuff is bad for brains. And I'd like to see fir...(Read More)