Tengoku British International School, Phuket
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search


Phuket Opinion: A dare to be honest

PHUKET: Patience is growing thin with the lack of credibility of any government reports about the current state of the COVID situation in Phuket, the vaccines being deployed and of any genuine concern for the people of Phuket during the ever-extended economic crisis.

opinionCOVID-19Coronavirushealthdeathtourismeconomics
By The Phuket News

Sunday 12 September 2021, 10:00AM


A small guesthouse in Patong sits empty as the shrouds wrapped around it start to fray. Photo: Chutharat Plerin

A small guesthouse in Patong sits empty as the shrouds wrapped around it start to fray. Photo: Chutharat Plerin

The latest debacle this week comes with the main SuperCheap store in Rassada being ordered closed for seven days over COVID infections. In announcing immediately after the daily meeting of the Phuket Provincial Communicable Disease Committee at Provincial Hall yesterday (Sept 11) that the megastore for cheap shopping located north of Phuket Town was to be closed, official reports gave the dates of the ordered closure as from Sept 11-17. Six hours later the actual order was released and the dates given were Sept 12-18.

That announcement came a full day after Phuket Provincial Health Office (PPHO) Chief Kusak Kukiattikoon reported to Deputy Prime Minister Supattanapong Punmeechaow that a cluster of infections already had been confirmed at a “large shopping mall”, which remained unnamed in official reports. Ironically, that message from Dr Kusak to Deputy PM Supattanapong was delivered in the very same room that the provincial disease committee sat in yesterday.

Meanwhile, Phuket Governor Narong Woonciew yesterday explained to the press that he had dispatched a team of health officers to the mall to investigate on Friday – again, a day after Dr Kusak had already confirmed to a deputy prime minster that the store was the centre of a cluster of infections.

The Governor has yet to explain, first, why the team was dispatched after the PPHO already knew of the infections; and second, why the order for the SuperCheap main store to close was delayed days after health officials already knew that it was the centre of a new cluster of infections. It’s as if either the two didn’t even know the same information despite sitting at the same meeting every day, or they simply didn’t have time to get their story straight before talking to the press. These days it is hard to tell.

Not lost on local observers is that this past week the PPHO map updated daily to show the number of new cases identified in each subdistrict issued each day – making it possible to track rises in the number of infections in each area – have been released later and later, at times into the early hours of the next day, with no explicable reason given. Also commented on online was that the map for Thursday was never released.

Even within minutes of being posted online at 11:29pm yesterday, the daily COVID situation report was already called out for being inaccurate for accounting for only two deaths. A local resident, a Thai national, pointed out that rescue workers had transported the bodies of three COVID victims yesterday. Laughing with “555555” typed in the post, the writer pointed out maybe the first death was too early for officials to notice. The man posted photos of rescue workers actually transporting the three bodies. There was no response.

With each passing day the people of Phuket are treated to a new stunning announcement. Last week it was that the Sandbox scheme had already generated B1.6 billion in income for the local economy. The only way that number could be achieved was to include all the daily spending of tourists but using the number tourists based on the room booking nights that have been prepaid under the scheme. Put simply, that means including daily money spent by tourists who have not even arrived on the island yet.

As for vaccinations, government agencies are heavily promoting how many people are now receiving their third dose booster jabs, while many people across the island still have yet to receive a first injection. Even according to the PPHO’s own report, as of Friday (Sept 10) 430,927 people in Phuket have received one vaccination injection, some 35,660 short of the target 466,587. Keep in mind that is while 480,303 people have reportedly registered through the PhuketMustWin website to be vaccinated. Either the local government does not have the vaccine doses to give to these people, or the people do not want the vaccines being offered. We are wondering how long it will be before any officials even recognise that.

Something is going seriously wrong with the reporting of the infections, deaths, the current economic situation in Phuket, and it is no longer a laughing matter of gross incompetence. It is now just plain insulting.

Of note, it was heartening to hear that Minister of Culture Itthipol Khunpluem was in Phuket in person this week to deliver the message from Bangkok for local officials to clearly report the situation accurately and in a timely manner so that officials can draft appropriate policies in response to the COVID situation as it unfolds.

It may appear odd that the Minister of Culture has a hand at this level of devolving COVID policy, but while Mr Itthipol may be the youngest of the Khunpluem brothers, it would be naive to underestimate the extent of influence that family has at the national level. We hope that local officials take heed of that.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

CAPTCHA

Kurt | 13 September 2021 - 09:12:11

Government hospitals are provided with resources according the official inhabitant figures. On Phuket the official inhabitant figures are to low, a big lie. Perhaps with purpose to keep costs of the hospitals low? Poor Thai who are 'victim' of that 'policy'.

Kurt | 13 September 2021 - 09:07:22

The word 'honest' in head line Opinion says a lot. We miss honesty in Official doings/figures. It are manipulated and/or partly given figures, hiding fact they not even know how many people living unregistered on Phuket, and are not on the radar. The absent of spirit/efforts to change that situation is astonishing. Visit Government overgrowded hospitals, struggling with fake figures

SEC2 | 12 September 2021 - 16:55:48

Vaccinations: I know many people that have not had even 1 shot. Also, their target of 466,587 is a joke.  There are a lot of people that live in Phuket that are registered in their home province.  There are at least 7 -8 Thai people within 2 blocks of my house that aren't registered in Phuket.   Multiply that by ? and how many people do you have that the municipality isn't counting living ...

PJ | 12 September 2021 - 11:51:32

Let’s hope the Thai language press and social media highlight the same issues then public opinion may actually count for something. 

 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Pla Wan Corner road safety project to begin

Nothing wrong with that road section. Just people driving in High Speed. Cheaper to set up Speed C...(Read More)


Phuket tourism industry turns to India

Indian tourists become Phuket business entrepreneurs? Great for diversity. But are Thai phuket busi...(Read More)


Ousted Sri Lankan leader to visit city

No humanitarian reasons were brought up by Prayut regarding forcing Myanmar refugees back to Myanmar...(Read More)


Pla Wan Corner road safety project to begin

Seems the repair/construction improvement of the bend hill Patak Road between Chalong and Kata must ...(Read More)


Pla Wan Corner road safety project to begin

Seems mr Vorasait is adicted to speed. Encouraged by 'service of RTP that not demand alcohol tes...(Read More)


Phuket Town businesses welcome Indian tourists

,,, I don't think the Tsunami warning bouys will work that well. Good luck....(Read More)


Phuket Town businesses welcome Indian tourists

"Love Marine Activities", all they've gota do is stay in a hotel on Patong Beach &...(Read More)


Opening hours for entertainment venues to be revised

Maybe they should all close @ 6pm. Far too many swords, guns, knifes & meth amphetamine on Phuke...(Read More)


Power outage to affect Cherng Talay

Thanks to TPN for these alerts. It's a testament to incompetency the PPEA cannot figure out wh...(Read More)