Login | Create Account Poll Currency Weather Facebook Youtube Search

Phuket Governor orders public vote on marina project amid concerns over coral damage

PHUKET: Phuket Governor Norraphat Plodthong has called for new a public hearing to be held on a marina project on Phuket’s east coast after dire concerns have been raised over the devastating effect dredging a channel there may have on an aquatic field of corals nearby.

By Tanyaluk Sakoot

Thursday 17 May 2018, 12:33PM

Governor Norraphat gave the order yesterday morning, before inspecting the corals in person yesterday afternoon (May 16).

Gov Norraphat also ordered Phuket Marine Office Chief Surat Sirisaiyat to investigate the potential damage that may be caused by the dredging and to report in detail about the project, the new B450 million Ao Kung Marina and sports complex in Pa Khlok.

Joining Governor Norraphat on his inspection visit was Watcharin Thintalang, Director of the Phuket office of the Department of Marine and Coastal Resources (DMCR), Sakorn Pudam from the Phuket Marine Office, Pa Khlok Deputy Mayor Namas Kertsep as well as officials from the Phuket office of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment (MNRE).

“I have received reports about this case from several officials, and I have been informed that construction of the marina has not yet been approved,” Gov Norraphat confirmed.

“The Department of Marine and Coastal Resources (DMCR) Phuket Office is supposed to know about this situation because these corals are in their area  of responsibility,” he said.

“I agree to hold a new public hearing on this,” he added, in response to requests by local residents concerned about the environmental damage the project may cause.

“Everyone needs to know the truth. All concerned officials must make sure local people join the public hearing,” Gov Norraphat said.

“Right now the project is under consideration by the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning. The decision of whether or not the project is approved rests with them,” he noted.

A date and venue for the public hearing has yet to be announced.

Of note, the EIA for the marina project was compiled by Enrich Consultants Co Ltd, the same company entrusted with conducting feasibility studies and EIA studies for Phuket’s multi-billion-baht light-rail project.

Also of importance is that the project was met with strong opposition at the second – and last – public hearing held in October last year.

At that meeting, marine ecosystem and resource management specialist Wankiat Thubtimsaeng expressed his concern about the construction of the project in the public’s interest.

“The area of Ao Kung is a very ecological area. As it is located on the east coast of Phuket, the seagrass beds and coral reefs are complete. Shrimp farms have a complete marine ecosystem, and this is the livelihood of the villagers,” said Mr Wankiat.

“During the construction phase, mangroves and water quality will be affected. Sedimentation and sludge diffusion will occur from large ships regularly moving in and out of the bay when the marina starts to get used.

“This will affect the ecology of the area as mangroves, coral reefs and sea grass will all be lost, so this project’s plans must be clear if it is to continue. We must maintain ecological integrity for the benefit of the locals,” he added.

Laguna Golf Phuket

Mr Wankiat also expressed deep concern over the lack of clear information presented on how wastewater was to be managed once the marina was built. (See story here.)

The entire project and the planned dredging of an eight-metre deep channel for boats to access the marina has long been opposed by local residents under the banner of the Ao Kung Bay Conservation Group, led by Pradit Puangket, who has campaigned against the environmental impact the marina project will have since its inception.

Of note, Mr Pradit, who is also the Phu Yai Baan (Village Chief) of Ban Ao Kung, has consistently clarified that he is not against the project itself – if the environmental concerns are addressed.

His main arguments have consistently been that the entire coast in the area is thicketed with mangroves and the area is blanketed with corals – so much so that even the small island in the bay to be directly affected is called Koh Hei, literally “Coral Island”.

The Phuket News on Tuesday (May 15) joined an inspection expedition to the coral site by local officials from the Phuket DMCR office.

Phatpong Romyen, who led the DMCR expedition on Tuesday declined to comment in detail on the project. “We came here to verify the location of the corals and report that back to headquarters. We can’t explain more detail right now,” was all he would say.

However, Pichet Pandan of the Ao Kung Conservation Group, explained, “We want to show this coral reef to the public. Also, we confirm that we don’t disagree with projects for Phuket’s growth. We know that such projects help to improve the standard of living of local residents, but the project really should be in another location.”

Mr Pichet noted that awareness of the project and its likely impact on the immediate environment had been building for weeks with posts on social media “going viral” online.

“However, we still have no clear answer what the next step for project will be. We are afraid that the project will ruin the marine environment. It is very possible that part of mangrove forest along the coast will be cut down, and many corals in the shallow waters here will die off,” he added.

Meanwhile, Village Chief Pradit has had the field of corals roped off to prevent visitors from walking into the area.

“We have hope that the Phuket Governor will realise the need to preserve this area, or that the DMCR will find a way to protect these corals as quickly as possible,” he said.

“We are just local residents here. We want to save it. Honestly, we don’t want to watch as these corals are destroyed,” he said.

While the focus yesterday was on the corals, another sticking point for the project is that in order for it to go ahead, it will require mangroves to be cut down, as the entire coastline along the bay is densely covered with natural mangroves.

As pointed out in the years-long battle to build the Thep Srisin Bridge at Saphan Hin, special permission from the Thai Cabinet itself must first be obtained in order to cut down any mangroves in Thailand. (See story here.)

Additional reporting by Eakkapop Thongtub



Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters

Capt B | 22 May 2018 - 08:46:21

Woops, good golly gosh. Hang on a moment, I'll get my violin out.Thailand has some of the best, most sustainable fisheries management practices in the world today. In any event, no need to dredge a channel through seagrass beds in order to make more room for recreational fishing vessels at the proposed marina. Recreational Fishing vessels = un-needed strain on Thailand's natural resources

BenPendejo | 20 May 2018 - 19:05:16

Based on my experience after seeing many controversial projects, the main selling of a project is done by wealthy interests with no interest other than their own financial interest. And, since there are very few actual professional resource managers, most of the decisions rest on how much cold cash and favors certain officials will stuff in their pockets. Natural resources usually lose.

Pauly44 | 19 May 2018 - 17:22:34

Overfishing small species also the destruction of Thai fishing, they net up everything with zero regulations, I used to sports fish for recreation strict catch & release 10-15 years ago around Andaman, now its not even worth it as there is not much left in the waters around Phuket, dynamite has also ruined many coral reefs, they don't use sustainable practices.

Capt B | 19 May 2018 - 09:59:33

Dredging, very ecological area, seagrass beds,  coral reefs, mangroves, sedimentation, sludge diffusion. Never mind the locals, this project will effect the livelihood of hundreds, possibly thousands of Commercial Thai Fishermen operating throughout the South West of Thailand. The Fishing Industry existed long before any tourist industry. DESTRUCTION OF SEAGRASS BEDS=DESTRUCTION OF THAI FISHING.  

Kurt | 17 May 2018 - 16:26:05

There is a small bucket list of Governor orders that are not yet carried out by Phuket government department officials
Why Governor not work on that first before ordering new things? So far it looks like ordering is just for publicity, not for purpose to be carried out. That is what Phuket society experience
A devaluation of ORDERING status on Phuket. Risk of not being taken serious.

Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Australian stabbed 12 times trying to protect Thai woman

I agree with CJ69 100%. However, there is a good chance that like the several 100K or millions of ...(Read More)

Second fire in three days breaks out in Rawai

Piled up/dumped garbage everywhere you look on Phuket. What is wrong with Phuket garbage 'cultu...(Read More)

Navy in motion to remove Phuket seastead

Bravo Navy!Who needs this things? Why not have a boat if you want to live on the water? Horst...(Read More)

Patong police, taxi drivers meet to discuss service, behaviour

always best to do this as high season comes to a close......(Read More)

In Big Joke saga, border patrol boss gets last laugh

Hope this new Immigration Chief continues with the idea of General Big Joke to stop with that 90 day...(Read More)

King cobra female caught in Patong, 30 eggs missing from nest

No need to investigate k, if you (I know you don't have any friends to eat with you) had Pad Tha...(Read More)

In Big Joke saga, border patrol boss gets last laugh what language was that comment written in?...(Read More)

Patong police, taxi drivers meet to discuss service, behaviour

This is kinda like the Principal, the School Counselor and a couple teachers getting together with t...(Read More)

Residents, hotels blamed for Nai Yang canal pollution

.. " One has no authority". Just dismiss yourself. Need other departments to come in and d...(Read More)