The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search


Pay for news: Why the world is watching Australia’s new big-tech rules

Pay for news: Why the world is watching Australia’s new big-tech rules

SYDNEY: Australia has moved a step closer to introducing legislation that would force tech giants to pay for sharing news content, a move that could change how people worldwide experience the internet.

technologyeconomics
By AFP

Friday 12 February 2021, 06:11PM


Australia has moved a step closer to introducing legislation that would force tech giants to pay for sharing news content, a move that could change how people worldwide experience the internet. Image: AFP / File

Australia has moved a step closer to introducing legislation that would force tech giants to pay for sharing news content, a move that could change how people worldwide experience the internet. Image: AFP / File

Here is a look at what the proposed rules are, why companies such as Facebook and Google hate them, and what it might mean for net users.

What is happening?

After two decades of light-touch regulation, companies such as Google and Facebook are coming under increased government scrutiny.

In Australia, regulators have zeroed-in on the firms’ online advertising dominance and the impact that has on struggling news media.

According to Australia’s competition watchdog, for every $100 spent on online advertising, Google captures $53, Facebook takes $28 and the rest is shared out among others.

To level the playing field, Australia wants Google and Facebook to pay for using expensive-to-produce news content in their searches and feeds.

After much back and forth, a senate inquiry concluded its review and issued its report on the draft legislation on Friday (Feb 12), recommending the measures become law with minor adjustments.

Why is it getting worldwide attention?

Although the rules would only apply in Australia, regulators elsewhere are looking closely at whether the system works and can be applied in other countries.

Microsoft – which could gain market share for its Bing search engine – has backed the proposals and explicitly called for other countries to follow Australia’s lead, arguing the tech sector needs to step up to revive independent journalism that “goes to the heart of our democratic freedoms”.

The US government currently opposes the proposals, warning of “long-lasting negative consequences” for US firms, but that opinion came days before President Joe Biden took office.

European legislators have cited the Australian proposals favourably as they draft their own EU-wide digital market legislation.

Why are Google and Facebook opposed?

Internal - Phuket Live Radio 89.5

More broadly, Facebook and Google are pushing back against a slew of potential regulation worldwide that threatens to undermine business models that have allowed them to become some of the biggest, most profitable companies in the world.

Concretely, both companies say they don’t have a problem paying for news – and, in fact, both already pay some news organisations for content.

Their main objection is being told how much they have to pay.

Under the Australian rules, an independent arbiter could decide if the deals reached are fair, to ensure the tech firms are not using their online advertising duopoly to dictate terms.

Opponents have also argued the new rules amount to a gift from Australia’s conservative government to allies in Rupert Murdoch’s Newscorp, the country’s biggest media group, to prop up his struggling newspapers.

What does it mean for me?

World Wide Web inventor Tim Berners-Lee has warned introducing the precedent of charging for links could open a Pandora’s Box of monetary claims that would break the internet.

"Links are fundamental to the web," he told the Senate inquiry. "If this precedent were followed elsewhere, it could make the web unworkable around the world."

Both Facebook and Google have argued that the proposals would spell the end of some of their most popular products.

Google Australia managing director Mel Silva told the parliamentary inquiry that if the rules are passed it "would have no real choice but to stop making Google Search available in Australia", a service which has more than 90% market share.

Similarly, Facebook has warned it could block Australian users from sharing local news stories on its platform.

While such moves in Australia would have little impact on either company’s bottom line, blocking these services more widely if the Australian approach was duplicated in other countries is unlikely to be an option.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

CAPTCHA

Be the first to comment.

 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Anutin, Phiphat arrive in Phuket, assure July 1 reopening

Sam Thompson, how many tourists do you think will want to come to Phuket to be told they cannot go f...(Read More)


Thais, foreigners arrested for drinking at Patong Beach

" Inferiority complexes" Lol Kurt, those words out of your mouth are the biggest joke of ...(Read More)


Anutin, Phiphat arrive in Phuket, assure July 1 reopening

I wonder if there is going to be a problem when we have 'fully vaccinated' tourists mingling...(Read More)


Jab-booking app for foreigners coming soon

Confusion indeed. After 2 weeks waiting I got confirmation yesterday from 'PhuketDtongChana'...(Read More)


Thais, foreigners arrested for drinking at Patong Beach

Thai civil Officials love uniforms with as much decorations as possible, as they are obsessed by sup...(Read More)


Anutin, Phiphat arrive in Phuket, assure July 1 reopening

OMG Kurt, the question from Snafu was about booking hotels after a possible opening on July 1. Noth...(Read More)


Thais, foreigners arrested for drinking at Patong Beach

Thai's arrested ? How is that possible. According to certain poster here they go after foreigner...(Read More)


Real Estate Market in Phuket: Pros & Cons

From advices in this article you understand not to burn fingers with buying Phuket property. Enough ...(Read More)


Anutin, Phiphat arrive in Phuket, assure July 1 reopening

@Snafu, Yes, since 15 May you only can go on 'scamming safari' through quarantine in special...(Read More)


Anutin, Phiphat arrive in Phuket, assure July 1 reopening

Hip-hop, hip hop. Hurry up, and wait! 'We' still learning how to govern a country. It is so ...(Read More)