Tengoku British International School, Phuket
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search


Pair of new studies point to natural COVID origin

Pair of new studies point to natural COVID origin

WASHINGTON: An animal market in China’s Wuhan really was the epicenter of the COVID pandemic, according to a pair of new studies in the journal Science published yesterday (July 26) that claimed to have tipped the balance in the debate about the virus’ origins.

ChineseconstructionCOVID-19animals
By AFP

Wednesday 27 July 2022, 09:37AM


Early COVID cases were clustered around the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan, China, a new study shows. Photo: AFP

Early COVID cases were clustered around the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan, China, a new study shows. Photo: AFP

Answering the question of whether the disease spilled over naturally from animals to humans, or was the result of a lab accident, is viewed as vital to averting the next pandemic and saving millions of lives.

The first paper analyzed the geographic pattern of COVID cases in the outbreak’s first month, December 2019, showing the first cases were tightly clustered around the Huanan Market.

The second examined genomic data from the earliest cases to study the virus’ early evolution, concluding it was unlikely the coronavirus circulated widely in humans prior to November 2019.

Both were previously posted as “preprints” but have now been vetted by scientific peer review and appear in a prestigious journal.

Michael Worobey of the University of Arizona, who co-authored both papers, had previously called on the scientific community in a letter to be more open to the idea that the virus was the result of a lab leak.

But the findings moved him “to the point where now I also think it’s just not plausible that this virus was introduced any other way than through the wildlife trade at the Wuhan market,” he told reporters on a call about the findings.

Though previous investigation had centered on the live animal market, researchers wanted more evidence to determine it was really the progenitor of the outbreak, as opposed to an amplifier.

This required neighborhood-level study within Wuhan to be more certain the virus was “zoonotic” - that it jumped from animals to people.

The first study’s team used mapping tools to determine the location of most of the first 174 cases identified by the World Health Organization, finding 155 of them were in Wuhan.

Further, these cases clustered tightly around the market - and some early patients with no recent history of visiting the market lived very close to it.

Mammals now known to be infectable with the virus - including red foxes, hog badgers and raccoon dogs, were all sold live in the market, the team showed.

Two introductions to humans

HeadStart International School Phuket

The study authors also tied positive samples from patients in early 2020 to the western portion of the market, which sold live or freshly butchered animals in late 2019.

The tightly confined early cases contrasted with how it radiated throughout the rest of the city by January and February, which the researchers confirmed by drilling into social media check-in data from the Weibo app.

“This tells us the virus was not circulating cryptically,” Worobey said in a statement. “It really originated at that market and spread out from there.”

The second study focused on resolving an apparent discrepancy in the virus’ early evolution.

Two lineages, A and B, marked the early pandemic.

But while A was closer to the virus found in bats, suggesting the coronavirus in humans came from this source and that A gave rise to B, it was B that was found to be far more present around the market.

The researchers used a technique called “molecular clock analysis,” which relies on the rate at which genetic mutations occur over time to reconstruct a timeline of evolution - and found it unlikely that A gave rise to B.

“Otherwise, lineage A would have had to have been evolving in slow motion compared to the lineage B virus, which just doesn’t make biological sense,” said Worobey.

Instead, the probable scenario was that both jumped from animals at the market to humans on separate occasions, in November and December 2019. The researchers concluded it was unlikely that there was human circulation prior to November 2019.

Under this scenario, there were probably other animal-to-human transmissions at the market that failed to manifest as COVID cases.

“Have we disproven the lab leak theory? No, we have not. Will we ever be able to know? No,” said co-author Kristian Anderson of The Scripps Research Institute.

“But I think what’s really important here is that there are possible scenarios and they’re plausible scenarios and it’s really important to understand that possible does not mean equally likely.”

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

CAPTCHA

christysweet | 27 July 2022 - 17:05:21

An earlier explanation is poorly trained  and/or oufitted  labworkers were in caves collecting bat  excrement for study and brought particles back to Wuhan. There was  a DNA sequencing study that pinpointed the cave, then the market amplified the spread. That theory ticks all the boxes re lab  and market 

 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Kamala to hold tsunami evacuation drill

@Oldguy...no, of course not. Have you ever heard the siren? And no...the buoys don't work...&quo...(Read More)


Bangla nightlife venues hold mass fire drill

Were the exits locked and blocked as they usually are? ...(Read More)


Phuket looks to tackle teenage pregnancies

Some Years ago I had a vasectomy so I wouldn't have children. When I got home afterwards, they ...(Read More)


Kamala to hold tsunami evacuation drill

Will the early warning buoys out in the Andaman be working? ...(Read More)


Kamala to hold tsunami evacuation drill

Does this mean the tsunami warning sirens will be working? ...(Read More)


Phuket Town police hunt beer thief

Silly beer thief. RTP catch him within 24 hours. 'Funny' crime doing. Unless it is a misun...(Read More)


New bill outlines limits on ganja use

This will not be the last bill. More relaxing bills will follow when the Officialdom panick dust has...(Read More)


Irate Thai tourists seek tour refunds

Do I understand correct that this is a article about illegal Thai business and Thai cheating Thai? H...(Read More)


Bangla nightlife venues hold mass fire drill

So, as 'key factor' in Tiger Discotheque was recognized, are all Phuket indoor night spots a...(Read More)


Phuket looks to tackle teenage pregnancies

Solution is simple. Start giving good sexual education in Mattayon-1. Classes with slides, film mate...(Read More)