The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Living on a knife edge

AFGHANISTAN: Afghanistan’s Jogi tribe live on a knife edge: forced to abandon their nomadic lives after violence wrecked their traditional wandering grounds, they still face daily discrimination trying to carve a more sedentary existence in a country that does not recognise them as proper citizens.


Sunday 18 March 2018, 10:30AM

An Afghan Jogi man looks at an empty bird cage at his temporary home on the outskirts of Mazar-i-Sharif. Afghanistan’s Jogi tribe face daily discrimination in a country that does not recognise them as proper citizens. Photo: Farshad Usyan / AFP

An Afghan Jogi man looks at an empty bird cage at his temporary home on the outskirts of Mazar-i-Sharif. Afghanistan’s Jogi tribe face daily discrimination in a country that does not recognise them as proper citizens. Photo: Farshad Usyan / AFP

Many from the ethnic minority opted to settle near Mazar-i-Sharif, the capital of the relatively peaceful Balkh province, where they have built neat, mud-brick houses on rented land but their position is precarious.

Afghanistan’s constitution does not explicitly recognise the Jogi as Afghans, making it difficult for them to obtain a tazkira, an identification document needed for any administrative procedure including buying the land they would need to settle permanently.

To obtain a tazkira the applicant’s father or elder brother must already have one.

The community’s leader Mullah Wural says they could be evicted at any time.

It is part of a pattern of discrimination and violence that the Jogi – also called “Jat” in Dari, a name as pejorative as “Roma” in Europe – have suffered since arriving in Afghanistan in the mid-nineteenth century from other parts of Central Asia.

These Sunni Muslims are distinguished from the rest of Afghanistan’s conservative and ethnically diverse population by their social customs – namely how women play an equal role to men in economically supporting their families.

Lightly veiled and wearing bright coloured dresses, they can be seen in Mazar’s streets begging and reading palms, a striking sight in a gender-segregated country where most women are kept behind walls.

“The Jogi are the most open community in the country,” boasts Wural.

But, though the Jogi men work also, often as day-labourers or caring for livestock, many Afghans accuse them of prostituting their wives while they stay at home and do nothing.

“The prejudice is so strong, it’s overwhelming,” says German anthropologist Annika Schmeding, who documented discrimination against the Jogi community in a 2015 report for NGO People in Need (PIN).

Playful 12-year-old Fodar jumps from one courtyard to another as a cow’s ear broth simmers in a pot and chickens busily peck at the ground.

He has managed to enrol in a public school because his family was able to secure him a tazkira owing to his father already holding one.

Because most Jogi are effectively stateless, they also have limited options to move beyond Afghanistan’s borders.

Musician Haji Rangin says he has missed out on gigs abroad because he does not have an identity document.

Sitting on a carpet between his son on the drums and his brother on a type of violin, he takes his long-handled traditional Uzbek guitar and strikes the strings with a hand adorned with little bells.

The sound draws curious children from the street to listen.

“I get inspired by my community, by my roots. Sometimes when I start the music and specific poems the men start crying,” Rangin says.

“I just wish sometimes to be counted as a citizen of this country... There is no discrimination when it comes to music,” he smiles.

“The problem is, to get a tazkira you have to get registered with somebody of your family who already has a tazkira,” says Schmeding, who believes that the tazkiras held by Jogi are often fake.

“It’s very difficult to check if it’s legal or not,” she explains.

Most Afghans do not consider the Jogis fellow citizens, no matter how long they have been in the country, she says.

Often politicians will not speak for the group for fear of upsetting the majority of the public.

“It’s a sensitive issue,” agrees Homayoun Mohtaat, director of the population bureau at the Ministry of the Interior.

In 2006, he says, the Jogi petitioned Afghanistan’s parliament for official legal recognition.

Official estimates put the total population at 20,000 to 30,000 people, mainly in northern Afghanistan. “So far, 1,300 tazkira have been issued, in Kunduz and Mazar,” Mohtaat said.

But the presidential decree that would give them legal status across the country is still pending. In a country with so many problems the plight of the Jogi is not a priority.

And even if it is delivered, discrimination and social prejudice may be harder to root out.

Schoolboy Fodar says he is bullied by other children at school.

He reveals: “Every day I paint something for them and I offer them the painting to buy peace; if not they beat me.”

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Be the first to comment.

Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Proposal for 4am bar, pub closing time draws fire

Weird. In the UK the argument has always been the exact opposite. Apparently shorter hours increase ...(Read More)

MP Sira files complaint to DSI over Phuket condo project The Peaks

Is this Karon/Kata Mayor the man who was a few years ago involved in matters in such a way that he w...(Read More)

No ban on plastic bags yet, says PM

Pledged to protect Marine Life, but same time sitting on hands till 2022! So, pledge has no value (T...(Read More)

Behind bras: GMS Duty Free calls for donated intimates for inmates

Why women still subscribe to strapping tight elastic and ridiculous thick formed foam to their chest...(Read More)

Proposal for 4am bar, pub closing time draws fire

Funny government discussion, specially when it concerns Pattaya and Phuket. There are illegal clubs/...(Read More)

Phuket officials file report of Lady D damaging corals

Who did order to tug that burning vessel to a shallow water coral area to let firefighters to pump /...(Read More)

Govt waives visa fees, not visas, for Chinese, Indian visitors

First a visa-waiver for 18 countries only. Enormous lost of countries income with a smelly discrimi...(Read More)

The Peaks Residences owner speaks out over land claim, public controversy

I am wondering why that guy start building the project without chanote. Thats the style here. Start ...(Read More)

Phuket officials file report of Lady D damaging corals

How does 4 years in jail equate with a fine of 40, 000 baht? Oh, wait- both have 4s in them?...(Read More)

MP Sira warns Governor of Amlo complaint over Phuket condo project

I'm pretty sure a recent commentator (who always delights me) meant payments made under the tab...(Read More)