Kata Rocks
THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search


Death of Myanmar baby in Phuket exposes chasm in migrant workers’ rights

Death of Myanmar baby in Phuket exposes chasm in migrant workers’ rights

PHUKET: The death of a Myanmar couple’s newborn baby at a workers’ camp in central Phuket earlier this month has exposed the lack of support by government agencies in ensuring migrant workers have access to basic healthcare under the law.

Myanmardeath
By The Phuket News

Saturday 29 February 2020, 05:48PM


Police officers inside Mr Ang and Ms Moe’s worker’s shack at the camp on Feb 13. Photo: Thalang Police

Police officers inside Mr Ang and Ms Moe’s worker’s shack at the camp on Feb 13. Photo: Thalang Police

Lt Phatkorn Pongpaiboon from Thalang Police was called to the workers’ camp, in Baan Lipon, Moo 5, Srisoonthorn, at 11pm on Feb 13 on being notified that a newborn baby had died at the camp.

At the camp, Lt Phatkorn and rescue workers met Myanmar couple Mr Ang Thu Lin, 24, and Miss Moe Khat, 24. Ms Moe was crying still cradling the body of her newborn daughter in her arms.

Lt Phatkorn explained, “We questioned the couple. They have been staying at the camp with their 5-years-old son for two months.

“Ms Moe became pregnant, and Mr Ang said they both went to Thalang Hospital to ask about any costs involved in having the baby delivered there. He said they were told it would cost B20,000.

“Mr Ang said he could not afford to pay that amount, and the couple planned to return to Myanmar and have the baby born there.

"But Ms Moe started having contractions at 7pm that night and was able to deliver the baby with assistance from neighbours. The baby stayed alive for 13 hours, and she passed away at 9pm,” he said.

“After we arrived, Ms Moe was taken Thalang Hospital to make sure that she was in safe condition,” Lt Phatkorn confirmed.

As the investigating officer, Lt Phatkorn said there were no charges to be pressed against anyone as he found no evidence of anyone responsible for the baby’s death.

“The baby’s death was not caused by anyone’s actions, and that is according to the result of the post-mortem examination from Thalang hospital,”

“I spoke with a representative from the company who hired the couple. Both are legally registered and have work permits and are registered with social security fund. Everything is in order,” Lt Phatkorn said.

THE HOSPITAL

Thalang Hospital Director Bunpot Pankhlueb said he had no knowledge of the death of Mr Ang and Ms Moe’s baby, or of any Myanmar people being refused hospital care because of lack of funds to pay for the treatment.

“I don’t know about any case about a Myanmar baby dying,” he told The Phuket News.

Seangdao Promkhan, head of the Management Division at Thalang Hospital, also denied any knowledge about the case.

"Generally, Myanmar patients come to ask about all kinds of medical costs at the hospital. There will not be any record when they come in asking for information,” she said.

The claims by Mr Bunpot and Ms Seangdao denying any knowledge of Ms Moe’s come despite Lt Phatkorn confirming that the hospital provided post-natal care for Ms Moe and performed a post-mortem examination on her child’s body.

“We have standard procedures for emergency cases involving pregnant migrant workers. Cases involving pregnancy are considered by the private insurance and the social security insurance,” Mr Bunpot said.

“The case of social security insurance is for normal circumstances involving giving birth. They have to pay first, then they can claim the get money back later. If not, hospital staff will contact the employer to confirm the migrant worker’s rights,” he added.

MACNELS SHIPPING PHUKET

As such, Mr Bunpot gave no explanation about whether or not hospital staff confirmed Ms Moe’s right to standard health care as guaranteed under Thai law.

Mr Bunpot also neglected to explain the B20,000 price that Mr Ang was told he would have to pay.

The provision of standard health care for legally registered migrant workers has been recognised by the World Health Organization (WHO) as far back as 2016.

One bulletin issued by WHO plainly states: “Migrants who have work permits are fully covered by the Thai social security scheme. This is a mandatory scheme financed by payroll taxes, to which employers, employees and the government contribute equal parts. Thai nationals and migrants who contribute to the social security system have equal rights of access to social security benefits, including health services.

Regardless, Ms Saendao made her position clear on the issue. “We will not follow up on this,” she said.

SOCIAL SECURITY

Peeraporn Borvontanasan, senior officer at the Phuket Social Security Office, also said she was unaware of the death of Mr Ang and Ms Moe’s baby.

“It is up to the employee to contact the Social Security Office. No one has contacted me about this,” she said.

“I don’t know why Mr Ang and Ms Moe did not go to the hospital. Employees covered by the Social Security Office are covered for up to B13,000 in fees for medical treatment for giving birth to a baby.” Ms Peeraporn added.

“Honestly, I have not been notified about this case. At this stage, however, it is employee’s responsibility to claim compensation for their baby’s death,” she said.

However, that understanding flies in the face of the action taken by the Phuket SSO in the horrific building collapse in the same area in Thalang in November that killed seven workers, when Wanarat Srisuksai, Director of the national Bureau of Occupational Safety and Health, under the Department of Labour Protection and Welfare (DLPW) of the Ministry of Labour, and DLPW Inspector-General Anan Bowonnaowarak inspected the site of the building collapse.

In that case, the Phuket Social Security Office was ordered to accelerate “the examination of various rights regarding remedies” for the workers, even though they were not even registered with the SSO. (See story here.)

Asked who is responsible for informing workers of their benefits, Ms Peeraporn said plainly, “It is Phuket Provincial Employment Office’s responsibility to tell all workers.”

THE EMPLOYMENT OFFICE

Phuket Provincial Employment Office Chief Santi Nantasuwan told The Phuket News this week that he too had no knowledge about the case.

However, now that the death of Mr Ang and Ms Moe’s baby has been brought to his attention, Mr Santi assured, “But now we are contacting the police to find out which company oversees the camp where the Myanmar couple are staying.

“We want to check that everything is legal with the workers and the company. We will try to find them soon,” he said.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

CAPTCHA

Rorri_2 | 07 March 2020 - 05:34:51

"unintelligible material that at best could be characterised as insulting," purely subjective, especially in Thailand where anything can be an "insult," yes even the truth, the truth, something othen forbidden,  something actively actioned against.

Rorri_2 | 07 March 2020 - 05:31:04

Jor12..mate, learn what hyerbole means, everyone, yes, even you, use it, time to grow up mate, try a bit harder to understand others point of view, then shiw some maturity by counting their arguement,  not just throw insults.

Jor12 | 06 March 2020 - 12:26:18

R...as stated in a previous post....demonstrates 
the rambling incoherent diatribe against various comentators, the contents of which contain argumentative and at times unintelligible material that at best could be characterised as insulting, which warrants your claims being ignored eg who exactly are "we all know..."

Jor12 | 06 March 2020 - 11:59:50

Get it into your head, I am not your "mate"

Rorri_2 | 06 March 2020 - 06:19:10

Jor12, mate, we all know you do not understand many things, even sarcasm.

Jor12 | 03 March 2020 - 12:27:54

Kurt...surely you must have a few clues? How on earth would a hospital know anything when parents don't present their child for treatment? Therefore, the hospital cannot be held to be lacking in support of anything.  Merely pointing out to R that if he is wrong to suggest I am his "mate" so no need to get angry about it.  You can find someone else.

Kurt | 03 March 2020 - 09:20:33

And khun Jor12, Read the top of the article again! : ..."exposed the lack of support by government agencies...".  A bit strange, that suggestion of you to charge the Burmese parents.

Kurt | 03 March 2020 - 09:12:09

@ Khun Jor12: The 'necessities of life' should have been provided by Mr Bunpot and Ms Seangdao of the hospital when birmese Mr Ang and Ms Moe came at hospital asking for help, instead of sending them away with a cold blooded 20,000 thb demand. A shameful hospital behaviour.

Rorri_2 | 03 March 2020 - 05:04:17

"My mates are more educated than you lot," wow.... seems like more rantings from someone on the verge of a breakdown, rambling on with utter rubbish, can only call others clowns, wow, so educated.

Jor12 | 02 March 2020 - 15:20:43

....Charge the parents with failing to provide the necessities of life.

Jor12 | 02 March 2020 - 15:18:06

Absolute rubbish you clowns. Read the article properly. My mates are more educated than you lot, so therefore you cannot be one of them. And what does article say about medical costs.?  "...Mr Ang said" and who is he? The father!  

Rorri_2 | 02 March 2020 - 10:44:10

Jor12, and yet again you descend into name calling, well mate, I would put us "clown" many steps above you.

Rorri_2 | 02 March 2020 - 10:42:38

Jor12, and of course everyone "follows" the law, how damn pathetic you are. All government bodies are covering their ass, and you blame the parents, who don't know the procedure... you poor excuse for a human.

Timothy | 02 March 2020 - 09:00:09

Hey you clown. Didn't you read the article where it says they went to the hospital and were told they would have to pay 20,000 baht? Someone should be charged here, but not the poor parents you pathetic apologist. 

Jor12 | 02 March 2020 - 05:39:09

Don't you clowns read or understand the article. By law Medical treatment cannot be refused. It is the ignorant parents who are fault here. They should be charged with failing to provide the necessities of life.

Nasa12 | 01 March 2020 - 13:06:17

R.I.P. to this baby girl. And of course  is a very common Thai still, refuse and refuse aaaand refuse.

Fascinated | 01 March 2020 - 09:47:29

'I know nothing', 'we will not follow up on this', and 'it's not my responsibility'. Typical response by a country that treats Myanmar workers as second class citizens and denies them rights they are entitled to. Shame on you all the officials named in this report.

Kurt | 01 March 2020 - 08:15:02

Many Government Agencies involved. Not one responsible, All finger pointing that away to others. No knowledge, denial,neglected to explain. Ignoring that the law is the law. WHO regulations? They don't care.
The way the Thai still house foreign workers in shacks, in this climate, is inhumane and a bloody shame.

 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
French tourists arrested for hookah party in Kamala

Ok Peace, let's not be racist, but we must admit that it is always the same people who are wreak...(Read More)


Immigration issues automatic visa extensions for all visa types

Well now I'm glad I went to immigration and did my 90 day report on April 1st, now that it turns...(Read More)


Chinese tourists questioned for illegal spearfishing in protected area

And now full force of the law on them! Double for the thai guide! Set a impressive example of '...(Read More)


Immigration issues automatic visa extensions for all visa types

How many hundreds needlessly exposed? Should have been done 2 weeks ago. ...(Read More)


Phuket Governor order warns of B20k fine for not wearing mask in public

@goldwing... these are emergency decrees by order of the government in order to prevent the widespre...(Read More)


Mains water supply outage in Rawai and Karon

r...how do arrive at your conclusion that the work is not urgent? As Pascale rightly points out, &qu...(Read More)


Phuket Songkran allowed, but stay in your subdistrict, says Governor

Bloomberg reporting Phuket infection rate at 36 per 100, 000 while Bangkok is at 21. This easing of...(Read More)


Phuket Songkran allowed, but stay in your subdistrict, says Governor

the shut down both the island and kathu is nt true. Please do what you annouced. My girl's relat...(Read More)


TAT issues full summary of COVID-19 restrictions in Phuket

my GF's grandma is still feel free to travel to Hatyai 2 days ago. And come to Wichit from Kathu...(Read More)


French tourists arrested for hookah party in Kamala

They are only French on their ID cards and whenever they want help from our government. They're...(Read More)