Everton have lost just one of Benitez’s first seven Premier League games in charge despite a limited budget due to financial fair-play restrictions and injuries to star strikers Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Richarlison.
A 1-1 draw away to Manchester United yesterday (Oct 2) kept Benitez’s men level on points with the Red Devils and Liverpool and one ahead of Manchester City ahead of the champions’ trip to Anfield today.
United boss Ole Gunnar Solskjaer could afford the luxury of bringing Cristiano Ronaldo, Jadon Sancho and Paul Pogba on as substitutes, while Benitez had to name three teenagers to fill out his bench.
But a point was the least the visitors deserved from a performance that married the defensive organisation Benitez’s sides are famous for with a potent threat on the counter-attack.
Everton’s goal showed the impact the 61-year-old has had in just a few months in charge.
After an Everton outlay of £240 million (B10.9 billion) in transfer fees over the past three years, Benitez’s spending was limited to £1.7mn to bring in Demarai Gray and Andros Townsend during the transfer window.
At the same time he had to shave down the wage bill with James Rodriguez frozen out before his move to Qatari side Al-Rayyan.
But Gray and Townsend have shone as Everton have taken 14 points from a possible 21.
Gray showed his blend of strength, determination and pace to twice dispossess Fred and set in motion the counter-attack for Everton’s equaliser.
Abdoulaye Doucoure is another player transformed by Benitez’s arrival and the Frenchman provided his fourth assist of the season by rolling the ball into the path of Townsend for his fifth goal in nine games as an Everton player.
Townsend was available on a free transfer from Crystal Palace with his career seemingly in decline but he has been revived by reuniting with Benitez after the pair worked together previously at Newcastle.
“The manager demands the very best. He got the best out of me when I was at Newcastle and he seems to be getting the best out of me again at the minute,” said Townsend.
“If I keep working hard, keep listening to the manager, hopefully I can continue getting on the scoresheet.”
But for a matter of centimetres Everton could even have grabbed their first victory at Old Trafford since 2013.
Yerry Mina tapped home Tom Davies’ cross in the dying minutes but the Colombian had just strayed offside, which was spotted by a VAR check.
Even a point felt like three for Benitez, given the side he had to cobble together due to injuries.
“It is a good draw, mentally like a victory, with the players who aren’t playing,” said Benitez. “If we have everybody available and continue with the same team spirit, we can win more games.
“Hopefully, we can bring back some players but be sure that we keep the same mentality, the same commitment, the same intensity.”
Calvert-Lewin, Richarlison, captain Seamus Coleman and Andre Gomes could return after the international break to bolster a bid to qualify for Europe next season.
That may be beyond a squad punching above its weight, but Benitez could not have asked for a better start to silence any lingering scepticism as to whether he was the best man for the job.
Meanhwile, Chelsea scored two late goals against Southampton to top the Premier League table.
Elsewhere, Brighton drew 0-0 with Arsenal to end the Gunners’ recent winning streak while Leeds earned their first league win of the season and Norwich avoided defeat for the first time.
Chelsea ended a miserable week on a high, with Timo Werner and Ben Chilwell striking late in a 3-1 win against Southampton, who are still without a league victory this season.
The three points lifted the Stamford Bridge club to the top of the Premier League on 16 points, two clear of Liverpool, Manchester United and Everton.
Thomas Tuchel’s side, tipped by many to win the Premier League in the early weeks of the season, were well beaten by Manchester City last week and lost to Juventus in the Champions League in midweek.
But they returned to winning ways in London yesterday, helped by a second-half red card for Southampton midfielder James Ward-Prowse.
Trevoh Chalobah nodded Chelsea into an early lead but Ward-Prowse levelled from the penalty spot just after the hour mark before he was sent off in the 77th minute for a dangerous tackle on Jorginho after a VAR check.
Werner provided the decisive moment, sliding in from Cesar Azpilicueta’s cross before Chilwell volleyed in from close range on 89 minutes to secure the victory.
“After two defeats we had to be careful that we didn’t start being too sad or too worried because there was a chance to be on 16 points,” Tuchel told the BBC.
“It was important to have a better performance than the last two games, that we sharpened our mindset so that we are not afraid to lose. It was nice to play the way we did and get a deserved win.”
Mikel Arteta’s Arsenal were bottom of the Premier League table after three matches before three consecutive wins lifted them to the comfort of mid-table.
But they were found it tough to break down high-flying Brighton in a soggy evening contest on England’s south coast with the teams managing just four shots on target between them in the goalless stalemate.
Earlier, Leeds beat Watford 1-0 thanks to a first-half strike by Diego Llorente while Hwang Hee-chan struck twice as Wolves beat struggling Newcastle 2-1.
Norwich stopped the rot against Burnley after six straight league defeats but they remain rock bottom of the Premier League table with just a single point from seven games after a 0-0 draw.