Kata Rocks
THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks

Thaksin faces new court strife

BANGKOK: At least five court cases, including four alleging corruption, against former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra are expected to be resumed in absentia following a new organic law endorsed by the National Legislative Assembly (NLA).

crimecorruptionlandpolitics
By Bangkok Post

Friday 14 July 2017, 08:32AM


Thaksin Shinawatra. Photo: Jiji/AFP

Thaksin Shinawatra. Photo: Jiji/AFP

The NLA yesterday (July 13) voted unanimously to pass the controversial draft organic law on criminal procedures for holders of a political position.

A critical issue of the law is that the statute of limitations has not expired while a fugitive suspect is on the run and that the Supreme Court’s Criminal Division for Holders of Political Positions can order a trial to proceed in absentia.

Cases which have gone to the court before the enactment of this law will also be affected, meaning the law will be retroactive, in legal terms, ex post facto, literally “out of the aftermath”. In general, rule of law forbids prosecutions under laws passed after the alleged crimes were committed.

Critics say the law has been designed for a specific purpose, to target Thaksin. There are six cases involving the former prime minister.

Chusak Sirinil, head of the Pheu Thai Party’s legal team, said the law is against the core principle of the constitution.

Of them, five cases have been suspended due to his absence. Thaksin’s abuse of power in the Ratchadaphisek land deal resulted in a two-year prison sentence handed down to him.

The five suspended cases also include four of alleged corruption in connection with B4 billion loans of EXIM Bank to Myanmar, the two and three-digit lottery scheme, amendment of satellite and mobile phone concession contracts, and Krung Thai Bank’s loan scandal involving the Krisda Mahanakorn group.

Another case is a libel lawsuit filed by the army. Thaksin has faced at least six arrest warrants for the cases, including the Ratchadaphisek land deal. Once the law comes into effect, the five cases against Thaksin could be resumed in absentia, NLA sources said.

Somchai Sawaengkarn, spokesman of the NLA committee vetting the law, insisted the law was not designed for any particular person but for any corrupt political position-holder.

NLA member Thani On-laiad cited the principle of the general criminal procedure code to support his view that to allow the trial to be conducted in absentia would be an act of violating the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights and possibly in breach of the core purpose of the constitution.

Atikom Intarabhuti, secretary-general of the Courts of Justice, who is among the minority on the NLA committee vetting the draft organic law that was fighting to delete from the draft the part about trials in absentia, asked that the provision be cut.

It is important that a trial is conducted with the defendant present least in the first round of it, he said.

That was to ensure justice, otherwise the defendant would later argue that a trial in absentia is unfair and when it requires cooperation from other nations regarding the deportation of that particular convicted individual back to serve the sentence in Thailand, other countries may refuse to help, he said.

“It would be better to adopt other legal mechanisms [instead of the trial in absentia option] such as to freeze the statute of limitations in the event the suspect has escaped during the trial,” he said.

“Another option is to improve the efficiency of the law enforcement organisation in tracking a suspect who is on the run.”

NLA member Thani On-laiad cited the principle of the general criminal procedure code to support his view that to allow the trial to be conducted in absentia would be an act of violating the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights and possibly in breach of the core purpose of the constitution.

“The first proceeding must be done in the presence of the defendant as a guarantee of justice. Failing that, the proceedings cannot punish the defendant, who may also raise the issue of justice later. Besides, it will make extradition harder,” said Mr Thani, who suggested other options.

“Seizing assets is possible if the defendant has fled. Or we could separate the criminal case from the political case.

“We should use other measures to prevent the defendant from fleeing such as excluding the time from the statute of limitations and improving arrest efficiency so we won’t be rejected when seeking extraditions,” he said.

But Pattarasak Wannasaeng disagreed. He said the principle applied only to the general public and this law would be used only against politicians, who could intervene with government agencies and interfere with evidence. Under the current system, “some defendants” are on the run until the statute of limitations ends, he said.

“I don’t think the bill breaches civil rights. We also make an exception that it can be done only after efforts have been made to bring the defendant to trial. Only then do we regard him or her as giving up the right. Besides, we don’t deprive him of the right to appoint a lawyer to fight the case and a retrial is possible if he is convicted.

“Moreover, the court will use the inquisitorial system where it can actively seek facts by itself. The defendant will not be at a disadvantage,” Mr Pattarasak said.

Read original story here.

 

 

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters
Username:
Password:
E-mail:
Security:

Be the first to comment.

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Rawai targets criminals, rogue drivers with B17mn CCTV camera project

Camera systems are fine, but you have to watch them 24 hours a day in control centres like they do i...(Read More)


Patong police net 13 suspects during Hi-Lo gambling raid

Problem with local Officialdom is they make a big poe-ha about small issues. The real big issues the...(Read More)


Rawai targets criminals, rogue drivers with B17mn CCTV camera project

Yup, real sufficient big speed bumps that can make they not drive faster than 50kmh in order to avo...(Read More)


Free legal service project on hold as ‘volunteer lawyers’ wait for budget

I remember that Patong police station did sack all the foreign tourist volunteer police who were spe...(Read More)


Free legal service project on hold as ‘volunteer lawyers’ wait for budget

Silly me, when I read the first article I thought that these guys were actually volunteering their s...(Read More)


Patong police net 13 suspects during Hi-Lo gambling raid

"The laugh stock of the month" Actually this price is reserved for you,every month. Luckil...(Read More)


Video highlights animal cruelty at Samutprakarn Crocodile Farm and Zoo

This National Geographic article will hopefully shame Thai authorities into doing something about th...(Read More)


Fast & Furious 9 to take on Phuket roads

That's already Fast and Furious everyday on Phuket Roads !! We won't even be able to notice...(Read More)


Rawai targets criminals, rogue drivers with B17mn CCTV camera project

Just install speed bumps in the underpass and no one can drive over 50. Do the same on rawai beach r...(Read More)


Patong police net 13 suspects during Hi-Lo gambling raid

If you like yourself as RTP , wow, in a joined operation (!), make yourself the laugh stock of the ...(Read More)