THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET
THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Phuket Opinion: Where is the justice for visa run deaths?

Phuket Opinion: Where is the justice for visa run deaths?

PHUKET: The fatal accident involving a mini-van from KBV Phuket Visa Run, which resulted in the death of three of its passengers on December 21, came as little surprise to those that have lived on the island for some period of time.

tourismtransportimmigrationdeathpoliceopinion
By The Phuket News

Sunday 1 January 2017, 09:00AM


The KBV visa run van driver was fined B150,000 for the accident that killed three foreigners. Photo: Phang Nga Rescue

The KBV visa run van driver was fined B150,000 for the accident that killed three foreigners. Photo: Phang Nga Rescue

Those who have lived here long enough are fully aware of the reputation of KBV’s drivers, and comments made on both The Phuket News website and Facebook page in relation to this news story should make the owner of KBV Visa Run and government officials fully aware of the reputation they do have, which, being frank, is diabolical.

But what did come as a surprise was that following the accident the driver of the van was charged with reckless driving causing death and injury and fined a measly sum of B150,000 for causing the death of those three passengers – or perhaps we should say “manslaughter” of those three passengers.

That same driver may well have been behind the wheel of another KBV Visa Run vehicle the very next day after he, or someone on his behalf, paid the fine. Who knows?

That penalty, if you can really call it that, makes it clear that any road accident that results in the death of a passenger, be they foreign or Thai, means very little according to Thai law. In this case each death was worth just B50,000.

Now let’s step over to the UK and look at a road accident that happened there in May 2014.

BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET

The driver of a bus was taking a group of 50 pensioner day trippers on a day out when he lost control on the bend of a steep hill. That accident resulted in the deaths, or should we say the manslaughter, of two of his passengers.

This driver was also charged and found guilty of causing death by dangerous driving. But the big difference here is that on August 22 this year the driver was sentenced to five years in prison.

It may have taken some 27 months for this case to be settled in court, but at least, according to one of the deceased person’s relatives, justice was served.

So a jail term of five years for causing two deaths by reckless driving compared to B150,000 for causing three deaths by reckless driving, is there really any justice in that?

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

CAPTCHA

Joe12 | 05 January 2017 - 22:00:38

The case of the jailed UK driver can be distingushed from this current accident as the facts differ. In the UK case, there was proven evidence of the driver talking to his mobile phone for some 8 minutes prior to the accident; excess water in the brake lines and speed. There is no evidence whatsoever of what the driver in this accident was doing prior to the accident, nor was there evidence of a v...

Kurt | 02 January 2017 - 16:15:24

CaptainJack69: Very well written! Very clear.
Now it would be nice if Thai Immigration offices do a bit more public relations regarding this matter.
Also Thai Embassies can do a good job to inform travelers on forehand.

No more dangerous and unneeded visa runs! Great!

CaptainJack69 | 02 January 2017 - 13:13:13

The only kind of 'justice' that can really come of this tragedy would be for everyone to stop using the 'visa run' service. But bearing in mind that most people getting on them are already well aware of their dreadful reputation and still choose to use them regardless, that doesn't seem likely.

For my part I'm surprised they're still in business. Thailand has ...

Kurt | 02 January 2017 - 12:07:04

Christy Sweet: I understand what you mean.
However, visa runs are done by foreigners. That was the subject.
But you are right, I should have separated that part of my writing ( foreign life value is just 50,000 thb = 1315 Euro's only) in a different alinea.
My apology.

Christy Sweet | 02 January 2017 - 07:53:48

Kurt,  I did not specify " foreign life.." IMO, it's pretty much all life and sprouting from a cultural motif of "you deserved to die," and "you'll come back."

LES | 01 January 2017 - 20:34:01

The local expat who use the visa run must surely realize these mini buses are death traps, just watch as they race one another back and to from the airport for example.
It is the unsuspecting new tourist who i really feel for, they take the minibus for a variety of trips in good faith, assuming that their driver will treat their safety as paramount, sadly lacking by evidence in most cases. Social...

Van Drivers | 01 January 2017 - 16:34:58

Van drivers are like taxi and tuk tuk mafia so some money may have been paid under the table to the authorities to avoid jail.

The advice here is to avoid:

Taxi's
Tuk Tuks
Vans
Buses

Kurt | 01 January 2017 - 12:35:24

Indeed, we live long enough on Phuket to know anything , in a negative way, about KBV visa run company.
And as we know, so of course thai authorities do, not at last the Immigration departments, know about this life threatening visa run happening very well.
It is simple, no thai authority cares about it. Much proof is there. Right?

The Thai Government thinking is simple: The KBV Mini Van Visa...

Christy Sweet | 01 January 2017 - 10:04:15

Thais simply have a completely different mindset when it comes to life and responsibility, but tourism officials like to pretend otherwise. Travelers need to be aware of this when deciding where to vacation.  Thanks PN for keeping it a public issue. 

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Phuket Poll: Environmental damage, prices too high

Great Phuket Poll. Now waiting for response of Phuket Officialdom as the outcome is significant. Sic...(Read More)


Phuket readies for HM King’s birthday

And presumably no alcohol ban? Since it's not a religious holiday? And you've made no mentio...(Read More)


Weather warning for Phuket remains in effect

As per usual here the Met. issuing a weather warning has proven to be the perfect way to bring the s...(Read More)


Phuket Opinion: Hit the dog

As bad as this was lets remember amongst all the angst that this is a DOG. Where is the uproar ofver...(Read More)


Brit expat behind bars for attacking Phuket dog

LOL. A few years ago a neighbor of mine would reach through my gate and hit my dog with a long stick...(Read More)


Egyptian tourist slashed with a cleaver on Phuket’s renowned Muay Thai street

Oh he used foul language while waiting buying a roti from the guy? I suppose that is fine as long a...(Read More)


Bridging Supply: Officials reveal B3.5bn proposal to resolve island’s water shortage woes

Maybe Mr.Fascinated could give us his own calculation for such a project instead of wondering about...(Read More)


Brit expat behind bars for attacking Phuket dog

"On march 15..." Isn't it strange that the same person is again and again involved in ...(Read More)


Phuket airport van B3k fare ‘just a misunderstanding’, say police

Mr Dek should look at the prices published at the transport desks in arrival hall airport. Moreover,...(Read More)


PM Prayut calls out Phuket van driver for overcharging Aussie tourists

.."Water shortage is always in April and May".. I thought really that we live now in the ...(Read More)