Kata Rocks
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Push for murder charges against drink-drivers divides force

Push for murder charges against drink-drivers divides force

BANGKOK: The government on April 5 ordered police to charge drink-driving motorists causing fatal accidents during the Songkran holiday with premeditated murder as it steps up efforts to curb preventable deaths.

By Bangkok Post

Monday 22 April 2019, 09:00AM

Wirachai: Ample proof for charges

Wirachai: Ample proof for charges

It is the harshest legal action ever taken against careless driving during Songkran.

The move is welcomed by some public safety advocates as a measure to deter drunk driving and save lives but questioned by some law enforcement officers who are concerned such a serious charge can jeopardise the case when it reaches the court.

Somchai Werotepipat, owner of Thai Carbon & Graphite Co, was the first person to face charges of murder and attempted murder in connection with drink driving after he rammed his Mercedes-Benz into a Suzuki Swift driven by Pol Lt Col Chatuporn Ngamsuwittchakun of the Crime Suppression Division on Thawi Watthana-Kanchanaphisek Road on April 11 night.

Pol Lt Col Chatuporn was killed instantly while his wife, Nutchanat, succumbed to her wounds later. Their 12-year-old daughter, Pitchayapha, sustained serious injuries including a brain haemorrhage.

Mr Somchai’s blood alcohol measured 260mg/dL just after the crash and he admitted he had been practising golf and drinking beer at a golf driving range before the accident. The legal limit is 50mg/dL.

Police pressed murder and attempted murder charges against him in line with the government’s policy to curb the traffic death toll. The other charges were drink-driving causing death, inflicting serious injuries and property damage.

However, those emerging concerns aired by law enforcement are coming into sharper focus after the Taling Chan Court on April 13 rejected the murder and attempted murder charges after finding no grounds for them. The court suggested the charge of reckless driving causing death and injuries be considered.

Deputy national police chief Wirachai Songmetta, who is in charge of this case, has insisted on keeping the charges of murder and attempted murder, saying police have “sufficient” evidence to back the charges.

Under Section 288 of the Criminal Code, a person convicted of the offence could be subject to a death sentence, life imprisonment, or between 15 and 20 years behind bars. However, Pol Gen Wirachai said it will be up to the court to rule on the case.

The case has yet to be submitted to the prosecution and at this stage, no charges against the suspect have been dropped, he said.

Senior investigators, meanwhile, do not see eye-to-eye over the policy and are concerned that if policy-makers have their way, the case could end up being eventually thrown out by the court.

A high-ranking officer at the Crime Suppression Division (CSD) with a specialised law degree said a premeditated murder charge has several elements including intention and a calculated plan to commit the offence while drink-driving causing death is about recklessness.

According to the officer, a charge of recklessness causing death should be pressed against the suspect in this case, as “twisting” the law as proposed could adversely affect the investigation.

Recklessness causing death is punishable by a maximum imprisonment of 10 years and a fine of 200,000 baht.

He pointed out that pressing both the charge of premeditated murder and the charge of recklessness causing death is likely to cause confusion as to what the suspect’s offence really is.

If investigators are confused, the case may end up being dropped by the courtwho will take responsibility?” he said.

A police superintendent, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said the case raises several questions.

Mr Somchai has rejected the charge of murder and attempted murder during police interrogation while confessing to the three other charges. “I’m worried about the children,” he said.


Read original story here.


Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Kurt | 22 April 2019 - 09:50:12

Harshest action, yes, but legal?  Have doubts about that.

Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Thai Navy seize IUU boat off Phuket

The photos not showing a fishing vessel. It is a empty ( perhaps partly refrigerated ?) cargo vessel...(Read More)

Phuket police bumble hunt for Norwegian killer

Lets just say that people staying and the Centara Grand aren't normally short of a bob or two. ...(Read More)

Digital Drive: Phuket police drop licence seizures in first move toward tech-based policing

Of note, the app. only works with newer licenses that have a QR code on them. If your license is mor...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: TM30 storm in a teacup

That whole TM 28/30 thing not works when Immigration only works 5 day a week, or sometimes 3 days a ...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Dangling the carrot

Guess the dangling carrot of Huawei en Berger is hanging to high in the air for Phuket Officialdom t...(Read More)

Digital Drive: Phuket police drop licence seizures in first move toward tech-based policing

can't see the point of this as half the people round here (Kathu ) don't have driving licenc...(Read More)

Phuket police bumble hunt for Norwegian killer

Norway has no extradition agreement with Thailand so if he comes to Norway case closed.This happend ...(Read More)

Governor requests B1.15mn extra to complete second building at new Provincial Hall site

No explanation was forthcoming. Ask smaller budgets step by step probably has more chance to get mor...(Read More)

Phuket police bumble hunt for Norwegian killer

TM28 and TM30 are mentioned here in other comments, Dek....(Read More)

Phuket police bumble hunt for Norwegian killer

Just a thought, Dek, just a thought. The article window doesn't matter as it is not a comment, b...(Read More)