THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks
Login | Create Account Poll Currency Weather Facebook Youtube Search

Phuket Poll: Opinion divided on Thai work permit

PHUKET: Opinion on whether or not to keep work permits is divided, with those calling for Thailand’s “little blue book” to be discontinued edging ahead, according to the results of a recent online poll by The Phuket News.

immigrationpoliceeconomicscrime
By The Phuket News

Friday 5 August 2016, 12:49PM


It's a close call, but more people say the Thai work permit is not necessary. Graph: The Phuket News

It's a close call, but more people say the Thai work permit is not necessary. Graph: The Phuket News

The poll, which ran online for two weeks, asked: “Is the Thai work permit necessary?”

That question was prompted by the news last month that a work permit is not required in order to receive income from renting out a condo, an announcement that brought much relief to expat condo owners across the island.

However, the disparity of that decision (see story here) compared with the need for a work permit for any other income-creating activities by foreigners threw the proverbial cat amongst the pigeons in a country where work permits are required by any foreigner even doing free volunteer work.

For decades the concept of whether or not money is received has been irrelevant as the definition of work in Thailand remains “engaging in work by exerting energy or using knowledge whether or not in consideration of wages or other benefits” (see Ministry of Labour website here).

In defence of the work permit, 39 per cent of those who took part in the poll voted, “Yes, the work permit is a valuable form of identification and should be upgraded to a photo ID card.”

A further 5% of respondents voted, “Yes, the work permit is a valuable form of identification and should be kept in the booklet form as is.”

Interestingly, 6% of respondents in the poll supported the Thai work permit in its current format while noting that it performed no essential function on its own, voting, “No, the work permit not necessary but there is no harm in keeping it.”

To all this support, a neat 50% of all respondents in the poll voted, “No, the work permit is pointless and should be discontinued immediately.”

To see the poll results, click here.

To see the results of our previous poll, which asked, “Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?” click here.

 

To suggest a poll, email execeditor@classactmedia.co.th with “Poll Suggestion” in the Subject line. 

 

 

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters
Username:
Password:
E-mail:
Security:

Kurt | 07 August 2016 - 15:07:00

@ Asterix, ...Silly Joe12. More and more he doesn't understand peoples comment, at least not respect it.
Just like to put down people. 
Sad for him, amusing for readers as Joe12 reads all my comments, and comment on them!! Sitting in his fish bowl.
So, he lies when he say not take any notice of my comments.

And the list of jobs reserved for thai is not that long.
It are jobs for none to...

Joe12 | 06 August 2016 - 20:05:38

Asterix...still don't understand the point of your comment. A lot of jobs are reserved for Thais only.  Sorry I don't take any notice of Kurt's comments because they are wrong anyway or way off the planet. 

Kurt | 06 August 2016 - 12:20:19

@ Asterix,  Many live aboard boats( 4-5 day trips) to Similans have foreign dive instructors who during these trips work as dive master.

My comment is not racistic.
I leave it up to you, saying that Thais are not xenophobic.

I not recognise myself in that part of your reaction.
It is totally not about that.

And if scuba diving industry is hitted hard, as you express, than look, analyse,...

Asterix | 06 August 2016 - 10:56:10

@Joe12
Yes I am correct... It had been confirmed by TAT Registration Office many times through media and at professional meetings about tourism and safety by the sea.

DIVEMASTER: Only Thai Divemasters may be dive guides to guide divers, Thais and foreigners, during fun dives.
All foreign Instructors are forbidden by Thai law to lead divers's groups for fun dives which is a job exclusively...

Kurt | 06 August 2016 - 10:02:36

Scuba Dive master is different from being a scuba dive instructor.
The 'steps' are: Rescue diver--> Dive master--> Dive instructor. ( see Padi dive training system)

Not many thai have the stamina to go through all this dive education/training, besides the fact that many thai believe that below the surface are bad spirits. 

So, here we have the thai situation: 
Unlicensed thai...

Joe12 | 05 August 2016 - 19:38:59

Asterix...First you say, "jobs are reserved to Thais only...forbidden by Thai Labour Laws". Then you state "...are able to teach dive courses only" Which is it - you can or can't work? 

This is the Thai way of protecting jobs for Thai nationals. It assists in generating more employment for the local population. Try working in any other country without authority and ...

Rich 44 | 05 August 2016 - 18:17:48

So....Technically;  If one helps the elderly lady who dropped her groceries one could get five years in jail or a fine of B2,000 to B100,000, or both? One is not even allowed to help another who is struggling to figure something out.
If this is so, I hope the work permit is abandoned. People should not be fined and/or jailed for helping others. 

Kurt | 05 August 2016 - 16:56:17

Mhh, I have been doing life aboard with several foreign dive companies to the Similans, with foreign dive masters.
Very skill full persons.
Their dive equipment was up to date according international PADI regulations, something we can not always say about thai dive companies, as they not that often clean the their air compressors, so you inhale dirty air during diving.

Thai government is not ...

Asterix | 05 August 2016 - 13:26:02

In Thailand, Divemaster jobs are reserved to Thais only and all foreign Instructors are forbidden by "Thai Labour Laws" to divemastering divers' groups and are able to teach dive courses only (Nature of work/Title/Occupation/Profession/Condition) on premise (Address of place of work) and the province (Permitted locality of work) written in their work-permits.

WRITTEN BLACK ON WHIT...

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
DPM Prawit tight-lipped since joking about Nairobi attack

DPM/ Minister of Defence Prawit better spend his energy on fighting and isolating the thai terrorist...(Read More)


New B25mn tsunami-warning buoy ‘to be operational tomorrow’

The two clueless ones can babble on as much as they like. The buoys are just an abject waste of time...(Read More)


Tout dumps slow loris with tourist, evades arrest at Kata Beach

Get it right. Again check the act. No point in making a comment when you dont know what you're ...(Read More)


Bangkok haze sweeps into surrounding provinces

Silly "Bangkok Post".Calling it "Haze" again.Our prof. on here corrected them al...(Read More)


New B25mn tsunami-warning buoy ‘to be operational tomorrow’

",,,when you live high/dry" In your case i believe the being"high" state,"d...(Read More)


TAT cultivates India as rich source of tourist arrivals

A rich source of tourists, but not a source of rich tourists......(Read More)


Phuket Opinion: ‘Reviving’ drowning victims

I'm a first aid instructor, but I would NEVER give CPR to someone in Thailand for one simple fac...(Read More)


Phuket Opinion: ‘Reviving’ drowning victims

Great informative article. Every Phuket beach life guard, all tourist boat 'captain's' s...(Read More)


US Govt shutdown prevents tsunami-warning buoy going live

The sane world really needs to focus on weaning itself from the US. The empire is crumbling and ther...(Read More)


Model claiming Trump secrets ’dragged’ into Russian detention

The only reason she was arrested i. Moscow was the Thai government turned her in. ...(Read More)