Kata Rocks
The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

More forensic evidence available for re-test, witness reveals

More forensic evidence available for re-test, witness reveals

SURAT THANI: Challenging previous testimony provided by police, a forensic expert told the court where two Burmese men are being tried for murdering British tourists on a Thai island that more evidence is available for the independent re-test requested by the defense team earlier this month.

By Khaosod English

Friday 24 July 2015, 10:21AM

Zaw Lin and Wai Phyo during police conference on Koh Tao on 10 October 2014. Photo: Khaosod English

Zaw Lin and Wai Phyo during police conference on Koh Tao on 10 October 2014. Photo: Khaosod English

Her testimony contradicted what police witnesses told the court during the first three days of the trial on July 8-10: that only four items were available for re-examination because other key pieces of evidence, such swabs of DNA taken from the victims’ bodies, were "used up."

Yesterdayʼs (July 23) witness, a scientist from police’s forensic division named Kewalee Chanpan, said that "all" genetic material tested in the lab is replicated for future processing.

Pol Lt Col Kewalee, who was in charge of testing several items in the investigation, also said that original pieces of evidence, such as a condom found at the crime scene, are still in police custody, though she added that DNA traces on objects diminish over time.

The availability of more forensic evidence is seen as a huge victory for the defense team, which has repeatedly protested their inability to access the alleged DNA match that police say incriminates the two suspects, whose names are Zaw Lin and Wai Phyo.

Police’s internal processing of the forensic tests – which were conducted privately in police lab – and the prosecution’s efforts to evade an independent re-examination of the evidence have fed long-running suspicions that the two Burmese migrant workers were framed.

In court this week, the two men, who must wear metal shackles around their ankles, have appeared engaged with the proceedings, but generally relaxed inside the courtroom.  

Although the forensic witness said yesterday that all genetic material is replicated as a matter of protocol in the police lab, she did not specifically confirm which samples can be retrieved for further examination.

According to the prosecution, the key pieces of incriminating evidence are semen found in the female victim’s body, and DNA on cigarette stubs found close to the crime scene.

The defense team told Khaosod English that they will discuss which pieces of additional evidence they would like send to the Central Institute of Forensic Science, a lab administered by the Ministry of Justice.

"We have to be specific about what we want retested, and for what purposes," said Nakhon Chompuchat, one of the defendants’ lawyers. "But at least our perception of things is now clearer."

Laguna Golf Phuket

He said the institute is still processing the items that were sent for a retest earlier this month, which included the bloodied garden hoe police believe was used in the murder, and a shoe, sock, and bag found at the crime scene.

Pol Lt Col Kewalee, who conducted police’s original testing of the garden hoe, told the court yesterday that only Witheridge’s blood was found on the weapon. No other DNA was found on the tool, she said.

When pressed by the defense about why there was no DNA found on the hoe that matched the suspects, who presumably had to grip its handle tightly, Pol Lt Col Kewalee said that skin cells from the hand are not as likely to adhere to an object as blood. 

She also did not supply the full documentation of the results she gathered in her forensic testing, citing a policy that bars scientists from providing investigative officers with detailed graphs of a person’s genetic makeup. 

The defendants’ lawyer, Nakhon, said he was suspicious of this reasoning, and has requested access to all of the material in order to ascertain whether any documents were tampered with.

"The prosecutor tried to be evasive by saying that no law supports giving the graphs and tables to the investigative officers, which is true," he said. "But once you testify to the court, you must show them."

He added, "I have already requested this information, but they won't give us. That is why I am suspicious."

According to Nakhon, the defense has not received a number of  requested documents from the prosecution, including photographs taken during the post-mortem examinations, and required paper trails – known as a ‘chains of custody’ – that document the collection, movement, and current location of all physical evidence.

"We haven’t received any of this," he said.

Read original story here.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Be the first to comment.

Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Smith's Ashes run-spree sparks Bradman comparisons

What an idiotic response by Mr Rorri. So you think the Captain of the Australian Cricket team cheati...(Read More)

Saving the elephant

ematt, many horse are very happy, otherwise they would happily trot over to there owners, obviously ...(Read More)

Thai airways reports loss of 122% in Q2

Mr Dek.. " therapeutic" dancing, is no different to a "therapeutic" holiday in a...(Read More)

Restaurant staffer caught in meth sting

Another team of criminals, without roots on Phuket. Convict and ban them for life from Phuket. Upgra...(Read More)

A beginner’s guide to caring for the island’s soi kittens and cats

Yet, no thought to the indigenous wildlife populations. Lizards, frogs, toads, snakes and song-birds...(Read More)

Thai airways reports loss of 122% in Q2

R2. please google "Waldorf school/Name dancing",you can learn something!...(Read More)

New Phoenix owner aims to restore wreck, return it to the sea

Interesting to see the helm, where the Captain was at the controls before he realized that he REALLY...(Read More)

Chinese tourist rescued from surf by Patong lifeguards

R2, how do you know what the life guards did and did not do? Were you there? Jeesh...,....(Read More)

Saving the elephant

How does the horse feel about having a steel bit forced into its mouth, tied up in leather straps, w...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Click to end the outdated TM30

Re: "my Thai wife and her wonderful family", and you subject them to your constant dispara...(Read More)