THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks
Login | Create Account Poll Currency Weather Facebook Youtube Search

Film Review: Oscar-worthy?

Hollywood, likes to stretch things out.


By Jean-Pierre Mestanza

Sunday 8 February 2015, 10:00AM


In re-telling the story of the man who helped break the “impossible” Nazi Enigma machine and decypher German intelligence codes used in World War II, The Imitation Game gives a history lesson without depicting much of the violence that ravaged that age.

The Imitation Game is a biographical film about Alan Turing, the man responsible for breaking the German intelligence codes that were thought to have been impossible to crack. The audience puts themselves in the shoes of Turing, a loner who fell in love with cryptography at a young age, as he navigates through levels of British military intelligence to finally help win the war for the allies.

Anyone with more than a cursory knowledge of World War II will know where this story goes, though it is interesting to see the obstacles that stood in Turing’s way: socially, at work, and through his own idiosyncracies.

Benedict Cumberbatch’s portrayal of Turing is fantastic and deserves his Oscar nomination for Best Actor. Keira Knightley, as Turing’s close confidant Joan Clark, gives a solid performance as well, but probably not as worthy for nomination for Best Supporting Actress as some other candidates this past year.

Given that much of the film’s action takes place within the confines of a British military base – in England – the absence of violence, apart from a few scenes, skews the sense of urgency. Director Morten Tyldum does a great job of ramping up the pressure with a few montages of numbers and bomber planes, although he falls short of depicting just how high the stakes were.

Since this is a film about a British mathematical genius, it’s done in a similar vein as A Beautiful Mind in which Russel Crowe’s John Nash character was aloof, distant and socially-impaired due to his schizophrenia. Turing is depicted in very much the same way (sans the hallucinations) and possesses qualities that would put him in the “crazy genius” category (even the music is similar to A Beautiful Mind).

This “troubled genius” is quite different from the man that Turing was, according to several sources. The brilliant cryptographer was far more well-liked and actually had a sense of humour. However, this depiction of Turing seems to go in line with how others viewed his homosexuality at the time and could have been added to provide more of an emotional impact, to empathise with Turing even further.

It’s no wonder the film was nominated for Best Picture in this year’s Academy Awards, it ticks all the boxes that Hollywood loves: covers a historical event, includes homosexual oppression, is based on a novel, depicts a troubled genius, includes British accents. And, just like A Beautiful Mind, the film was also nominated for the big three Oscar categories (Actor, Picture, Director).

The Imitation Game is up to par with the best films of the year, but will most likely not win the award. Still, it’s a great film that brings about an appreciation for the man whose work changed the world.

Four Stars!

The Imitation Games

Starring:
Benedict Cumberbatch, Keira Knightley, Matthew Goode,
Rory Kinnear,
Charles Dance
and Mark Strong
Director:
Morten Tyldum
Running time:
114 minutes


 

 

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters
Username:
Password:
E-mail:
Security:

Be the first to comment.

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Amnesty strips Aung San Suu Kyi of highest honour

Very Good! Pity that Nobel Price regulations not able to cancel/take back a Nobel Price. Perhaps wi...(Read More)


Phuket man nabbed with over 52,000 ya bah pills, ya ice

Many coffee shops closing down,rules of selling weed getting stricter.They are tolerant towards soft...(Read More)


Finances blamed for Phuket DJ suicide

Dekas,you nailed it ! Whenever i thought it can't get any lower here,the one person comes up and...(Read More)


Amnesty strips Aung San Suu Kyi of highest honour

It is usually a terrible mistake to use role models to promote progressive agendas. It usually back...(Read More)


Weather warning for Phuket remains in effect

Hardly any rain last few days, and almost no wind. Strange weather report. So, how are things going ...(Read More)


Finances blamed for Phuket DJ suicide

@ Wiesel, I love Thailand and the thai people. I not like thai officials incompetence, lack of law ...(Read More)


Phuket man nabbed with over 52,000 ya bah pills, ya ice

Pascale, like me, you could have seen BBC World and CNN about the Dutch tolerance, and thai visitors...(Read More)


Wildlife officials arrest slow loris tout at Bang Tao Beach

7 RTP officers ( in office) on a slow loris case. A case brought up mostly by others ( tourists) as ...(Read More)


Finances blamed for Phuket DJ suicide

@DEK, so, it is not a campaign against officials, they campaign against themselves all the time, you...(Read More)


Finances blamed for Phuket DJ suicide

@ DEK, understand many jobs gone/going due to the official regimental small thinker tourist approach...(Read More)