THE PAVILIONS PHUKET BRITISH INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, PHUKET Kata Rocks
Login | Create Account Poll Currency Weather Facebook Youtube Search

EU slams govt’s fishing ‘propaganda campaign’

BANGKOK: The European Union (EU) has slammed Thailand’s “propaganda campaign” to publicise the “positive side” of its efforts to clamp down on illegal fishing and criticised the country for not doing enough to address the problem.

immigrationeconomicsmarinecrimecorruptionpolitics
By Bangkok Post

Saturday 23 April 2016, 10:10AM


Fishing boats tie up in a harbour in Ban Laem district in Phetchaburi on Feb 16, 2016. Photo: Bangkok Post / Thanarak Khunton

Fishing boats tie up in a harbour in Ban Laem district in Phetchaburi on Feb 16, 2016. Photo: Bangkok Post / Thanarak Khunton

The EU is also considering if it will postpone its next meeting with Thai delegates scheduled for May.

The criticism appeared in a document obtained by the Bangkok Post related to talks on Tuesday (Apr 19) between Atinant Intarapim, deputy director of the Office of Agricultural Affairs based in the EU, and Adela Rey and Olalla Perez, representatives of the European Commission's Directorate-General for Maritime Affairs and Fisheries (DG MARE).

According to the document, DG MARE thinks that while the Thai government has shown determination to solve illegal fishing, in practice it falls short.

As a result, DG MARE has lost confidence in the Thai government’s operational units, law enforcement, and its implementation of the Fishery Management Plan to deal with illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing.

DG MARE believes several measures can be implemented straight away such as revoking licences of illegal fishing vessels and seafood processing plants.

Moreover, the government declared that it resolved 99 per cent of the problem, which contradicted information received by DG MARE.

DG MARE representatives also told their Thai counterpart that the Thai government’s campaign to publicise its efforts to address IUU issues had an adverse impact on their views.

Thailand only presented positive information through the media and this could lead to other EU member countries believing that the agency's assessment of Thailand was unreliable.

It cited an article in The Economist which reported Thailand’s progress in solving illegal fishing as a form of “propaganda” pushed by the Thai government.

DG MARE representatives also said Thailand lacks accurate information related to fishing vessels, and there was no information regarding fishing vessels equipped with Vessel Monitoring Systems and ones without the systems.

This showed anti-illegal fishing operations do not comply with the Fishery Act or the Fishery Master Plan. DG MARE also noted that the government has bowed to private sector pressure.

DG MARE hopes to get a better picture of which legal measures will be enforced to support the Fishery Act, measures already in force and measures that do not require urgent enforcement. The agency said that it has not received such information.

Government announcements that contradict or duplicate the main laws should be scrapped to avoid confusion, the agency said.

QSI International School Phuket

DG MARE said that it does not want to give Thailand a red card but the Thai government needs to display concrete problem-solving steps.

In another document obtained by the Bangkok Post, Virachai Plasai, Thailand’s permanent representative to the United Nations, wrote to tell the Foreign Ministry about his telephone conversation with Cesar Deben, DG MARE's principal IUU adviser.

Mr Deben expressed concern about Thailand’s problems and thought the country had been plagued with operational issues in its implementation of the action plans issued to combat IUU.

A lack of information from Thailand also demonstrated that the country had no “political will” to act on agreements, Mr Virachai quoted Mr Deben as saying.

Mr Deben also said that even though Thailand has shown it is trying as hard as it can to address IUU issues, the country still has some problems that require in-depth solutions. Mr Deben went on to say that “the country’s political problem and the issues related to the country’s new constitution could complicate efforts to address the IUU problems”.

DG MARE is asking Thailand for its opinion on the possibility of postponing a meeting scheduled for May as the postponement would give Thailand more time to comply with previous agreements.

Responding to the criticism over the “propaganda campaign”, Vice Admiral Jumpol Lumpikanon, spokesman of the Command Centre for Combating Illegal Fishing, said the Foreign Ministry had already explained the matter, and the ministry admitted that the information in foreign media had been used for public relations.

“Once foreign media incorrectly accused us, we had to clarify. It is normal practice. If the EU disagrees with the information, it can alert us so the government can make improvements,” he said.

V/Adm Jumpol admitted that there could be some lack of clarity in the implementation of policies to deal with IUU fishing as the country’s fishing industry is in a process of transition.

Of the 91 laws related to the fishing industry, 49 have been enacted. Each legislative bill requires scrutiny by the Council of State, which is the government’s legal advisory body, and then deliberation by the National Legislative Assembly, V/Adm Jumpol said.

The Thai government on Wednesday removed Fisheries Department chief Wimol Jantrarotai and accused him of slow progress in addressing illegal fishing amid concerns Thailand is still at risk of being slapped with a red card by the EU.

 

Read original story here.

 

 

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters
Username:
Password:
E-mail:
Security:

Joe12 | 07 May 2016 - 09:49:46

More doom and gloom from the dommsayers Mut and Jeff. You will note that The Royal Ordinance on Fisheries B.E. 2558 (2015) came into force on 14 November 2015, replacing the recently amended Fisheries Act B.E. 2558 (2015). Staff have been recruited, trained and stationed accordingly. Obviously the pace of change is not to Mut and Jeff's liking given the level of their distaste for things Thai....

Richard Vickers | 23 April 2016 - 14:26:50

This issues shines much light on just how clueless high-ranking Thai officials are when dealing with the western world.  They continue to think they can just keep on spouting nonsensical b*llsh*t  and that the masses will simply say "Oh...OK, if you say so". Thais officials haven't done anything very meaningful to combat the poor fisheries and environmental management, as well as add...

Kurt | 23 April 2016 - 10:43:31

Very good that the EU/DG MARE is able to look through the thai fishing propaganda campaign.
I was laughing about that ' 99% resolved' thing.

It reminded me about Patong beach where the 'bloom/polluted beach water propaganda campaign did fall apart by admitting that at least 20% of the waste water was untreated released into Patong Beach Bay.

As that 99% figure is not true, the s...

Have a news tip-off? Click here

 

Phuket community
Phuket Immigration to launch ‘Drive Thru’ service

Great laughing, a 90 day report like a Mc Donald drive through? See the number of people waiting in ...(Read More)


Immigration Chief Surachate to inspect new Phoenix salvage attempt

Yes .... perhaps hard to imagine for you, but foreigners called in to do a job thai can't do it ...(Read More)


Phuket Immigration to launch ‘Drive Thru’ service

So there will be a line of cars with the motors running, emitting exhaust fumes? This picture implie...(Read More)


Phuket Immigration to launch ‘Drive Thru’ service

Nice,if it would work ! Something i doubt....(Read More)


Immigration Chief Surachate to inspect new Phoenix salvage attempt

"He will be disappointed that the singaporean salvage team not will wai or take notice of him&q...(Read More)


Phuket Immigration to launch ‘Drive Thru’ service

Ah genuis..let the online reporting site be run down and waste 1000's of people 1000's of ho...(Read More)


Phuket Police ready for Loy Krathong

As many thai on Phuket go Lake Naiharn, let's see how authorities/RTP anticipate the enormous tr...(Read More)


Immigration Chief Surachate to inspect new Phoenix salvage attempt

Seems until now Immigration General becomes the highest authority to 'inspect' the disaster ...(Read More)


Amnesty strips Aung San Suu Kyi of highest honour

@ bojon. It was the latest of a string of awards she lost., including Canadian honorary citizenship...(Read More)