The Phuket News Novosti Phuket Khao Phuket

Login | Create Account | Search

Phuket Opinion: Falling into the Seychelles hole

Phuket Opinion: Falling into the Seychelles hole

PHUKET: The rush to roll out the mass vaccination of people using the Chinese-made Sinopharm vaccine ‘CoronaVac’ has come home to roost in the Seychelles, the world-famous island tourist destination that Phuket officials have used as an example to follow.

By The Phuket News

Sunday 9 May 2021, 12:32PM

There are many better vaccine options now available. Photo: AFP

There are many better vaccine options now available. Photo: AFP

** Correction: The original article mistakenly identified that the Seychelles used the Sinovac vaccine ’CoronaVac’ to vaccinate some 60% of its residents. It did not. The Seychelles used the Chinese-made Sinopharm vaccine. The error is sincerely regretted and the article has been corrected to reflect this. The rest of the article remains unchanged.

This past week authorities in the Seychelles have ordered schools closed and a raft of other emergency provisions to try halt the spread of COVID-19 infections that has ripped through the island nation, which recorded close to 500 new cases in the three days to 1 May among a population of just under 100,000.

The country’s news agency reported that of the current ongoing infections, about 1,000 were “active cases”. One third of those active cases were people who had received two vaccine doses of CoronaVac.

The same has happened in Chile and Turkey, which both used the Sinovac vaccine for their mass-vaccination campaigns.

The is no reason to believe that Phuket will fare any better than any of these countries if the platform for vaccination protection of people across the island is based on the same vaccine.

Of note, Seychelles is a world leader in the percentage of its population that have received vaccination injections, underlining the issue that reaching the ‘herd immunity’ target of vaccinating 70% of the population appears pointless if achieved with a vaccine with a low efficacy in preventing infections.

With the announcement by the Phuket Governor that Phuket is pushing ahead with its goal of reopening the island to receiving fully vaccinated international tourists without quarantine from July 1, the ability of the Chinese-made vaccine Sinovac to prevent COVID infections has been placed front and centre.

Of course there are many deeper questions about the Seychelles outbreak that need better explanation, including how serious the infections are.

Internal - Phuket Live Radio 89.5

As for the Sinovac vaccine, it  has been long and oft-repeated that the  vaccine has a poor 50.4% ability to prevent infections. Its sales point has been that it prevents people infected with the virus from developing serious symptoms, and apparently has a very good record at preventing deaths.

Further, if the infections are amounting to very little danger to the people infected, the Chinese vaccine used in the Seychelles may have done its job, and the shutdowns ordered by the Seychelles authorities can be considered nothing more than a prudent measure. Right now, it is too early to tell.

However, while Phuket health officials have already marked that of the current infections across the island of the B117 variant of the virus about 50% of the infected people are asymptomatic, the real concern lies with later infections of more dangerous variants such as the one currently devastating India.

All this leads to deep concerns that with the July 1 deadline looming, the rush to place such trust in the Chinese vaccine may be misplaced, and cost the island much more dearly in the long run.

As one The Phuket News reader eloquently put it, “Right now they’re rushing towards a date with an inferior solution.”

The Phuket News has long advocated for the right of choice of vaccine for people to choose from so they determine their own level of protection, and we have openly criticised the government for failing to allow that choice. The reasons so far given to the public for the delay in allowing better-performing vaccines have lacked any modicum of credibility. So far it still appears that the central government is dedicated to upholding a business deal made last year, while the circumstances have changed greatly since then.

The time to take a moment of pause about the real ability of protecting Phuket people from having to shut down again after reopening on July 1 is now upon us, simply due to which vaccine is being trusted to allow the reopening of tourism to the island – all based on a decision made more than eight months ago.

Other options are now on the table. They are worth considering.

What must be recognised, however, is that any change will come at extra cost to what remains in the government’s coffers, and will likely delay the July 1 tourism reopening.

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.


Pascale | 10 May 2021 - 16:51:57

@Kurt   Please do your own research on prices for Covid Vaccines ! 

Kurt | 10 May 2021 - 10:36:05

@ Pascale, Mention me the price of Sinovac and other, according you, cheaper vaccines. But not in Thailand, right? Till today chinese vaccines not approved by USA, Canadian and European FDA's. Perhaps same counts for Australia/New Zealand/Japan?

Pascale | 10 May 2021 - 09:43:04

@Kurt There are cheaper vaccines than Sinovac. ill you ever understand that ?
@ PN  Very embarrassing your error ! You should correct the whole article, as certain reader/serial whinger won't get it.

[Embarrassing - agreed. But it actually makes the argument even stronger: Sinopharm 67% effective at preventing infections; Sinovac 50.4%. The concerns remain - Ed]

Kurt | 09 May 2021 - 16:28:22

Great Opinion, pointing out that using a very little efficacy vaccine brings Thailand further away from what the country aims. It's wasting time, energy, money, and will not reach it goals. And herd immunity? Dream on, forget about that with Sinovac. Cheap vaccination will in time work out to be disastrous expensive time wasting. Than back to square 1.

CaptainJack69 | 09 May 2021 - 14:00:06

Like allowing private hospitals to sell the 94% effective Moderna vaccine for 3000B instead of citing mysterious "conflict of interests".

Christy Sweet | 09 May 2021 - 13:49:36

Thank you TPN Editor! Crap- O- Vac is not going to save Phuket Tourism from ineptitude, only a 3 week total  shut down can Start it now  or watch the entire summer season evaporate as countries restrict travel  to Thailand.  

jsrit | 09 May 2021 - 12:56:09

A major distinction is that all visitors entering the Seychelles should have a negative PCR test. They do not require tourists to be vaccinated. Phuket will require tourists be vaccinated on July 1st. Therefore we are much less likely to see spikes in cases or outbreaks of other variants.

Also the Thai-made British jabs are coming to Phuket soon! Great article, but tell the whole story please.


Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Oil spill tar balls wash ashore at Patong, Nai Yang

“tar balls” and debris on the beach is what tourist expect to find when going to a tropical beac...(Read More)

Govt confirms Phuket 62% vaccinated

What is it with whiners' reliance on ad hominem attacks in lieu of discourse? Couldn't arg...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Fingers crossed for July 1

It's not the foreign visitors who'll bring Covid, it's the expected "500,000" ...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Fingers crossed for July 1

To say that "whatever is opened can still be closed” is not best way to promote tourists book...(Read More)

Phuket Sandbox: Are we ready?

We are now past the safe threshold for expat retirees to have been inoculated fully. Has any retiree...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Fingers crossed for July 1

I don't believe the "reopening" is very dangerous. Realistically people aren't goi...(Read More)

Phuket fisheries chief defends blacktip shark fishing, ‘not illegal’

It's his job to make it illegal. Sharks are apex predator's and essential to the health of t...(Read More)

Govt confirms Phuket 62% vaccinated

Wow, just reading these comments. What a miserable, complaining, disgruntled lot of expats we have h...(Read More)

Long-stay ’O-A visa’ holders will need virus cover

Firstly, would we still need to take out the insurance or bank the money if we are fully vaccinated?...(Read More)

Phuket Sandbox: Are we ready?

If its too dangerous to open pubs and clubs then, hell no, we're not ready!...(Read More)