Defence to appeal Koh Tao verdicts

SURAT THANI: The defence in a case where two Myanmar nationals were convicted of the brutal murders of two British backpackers in Koh Tao in September 2014, will file their final appeal with the Supreme Court today (Aug 21).

By Bangkok Post

Monday 21 August 2017, 08:51AM

Koh Tao murder suspects Wyn, left, and Saw re-enact their alleged killing of two British backpackers. Photo: Tawatchai Khemgumnerd

Koh Tao murder suspects Wyn, left, and Saw re-enact their alleged killing of two British backpackers. Photo: Tawatchai Khemgumnerd

The defence will argue against the reliability of forensic evidence and legality of the investigation process in their appeal, said Nakhon Chompuchat, head of the defence team.

Lawyers of 22-year-olds, Zaw Lin and Win Zaw Htun, the latter also known as Wai Phyo, will file the appeal with the Supreme Court against the Appeal Court’s ruling in March upholding the death sentence handed down to the two migrant workers for the rape and murder of Hannah Witheridge, 23, and the murder of David Miller, 24, on the resort island on Sept 15, 2014.

Mr Nakhon told the Bangkok Post he will submit a 300-page appeal to the Supreme Court today, focusing on two key arguments.

He said a key issue the defence lawyers will argue is the forensic procedure and autopsy results that confirmed a match in the DNA found in samples collected from Ms Witheridge’s body and the DNA of the defendants.

According to the Appeal Court ruling, the results were in line with international standards and the defendants committed the crime “without a doubt”, Mr Nakhon said.

He said the defence lawyers would point out to the Supreme Court that there still remained some “doubt” regarding the forensic evidence, including the DNA test, as the sample collection, analysis and reporting procedures may not be fully reliable.

He said the defence would argue to the Supreme Court that those procedures were not in line with “international standards of forensic science”.

In addition, the lawyer said his team would argue the official autopsy results were not submitted to the lower courts, only verbal statements of witnesses and experts were given. So, there are doubts over the autopsy results as well, the lawyer said.

Mr Nakhon said poor handling and problems with chain of custody regarding the DNA samples during the police investigation process would be another issue they would raise in their appeal.

The defence team believes the police interrogation process was unlawful, he said.

Initially, he said, the defendants were questioned as witnesses.

But it turned out the police were later in possession of their confessions over the rape and murder.

The defendants had no lawyer participating in the interrogation, he said.

In addition, the defendants were never properly advised of the murder charges, nor their rights under Thai law. They were also not provided with a proper interpreter during the process.

The defence lawyers will point out the defendants’ confessions during the investigation process are unreliable as they were given under duress and intimidation, said Mr Nakhon.

Both defendants later retracted their confessions.

“Given such a suspicious interrogation process, we will ask the court not to accept its results,” he said.

Mr Nakhon said representatives of the Myanmar government met his team on Tuesday last week (Aug 15) to coordinate with them and also extend their gratitude to the Lawyers Council of Thailand for providing legal help to the Myanmar defendants.

Last Thursday (Aug 17), the lawyers met the defendants at Bang Kwang Central Prison to read to them the details of the appeal and get their signature of approval.

The defendants said they still hope for justice, said Mr Nakhon.

In March, the Appeal Court Region 8 upheld the death sentence for both migrant workers.

The court said the defence team’s argument regarding the absence of certain evidence was not grounds for the court to question the handling of the investigation.

According to the court, numerous steps were involved including photo-taking at the crime scene and also during the examination of evidence.

It was impossible to document or take photos of the entire procedure, it said.

The fact the prosecution did not submit some photos as evidence, such as samples collected from Ms Witheridge’s private parts, was not enough to question the handling of the case.

According to the court, the sentence was reached not based on a single photo or document, but several pieces of evidence that were connected.

Read original story here.



Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters

Be the first to comment.

Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Fast & Furious 9 to take on Phuket roads

A governor plays the trumpet about very temporarily 'backround employment' during a movie sh...(Read More)

Government discloses Senate selectors

The Junta said 'thanks' to the Senate selectors for their service to the Junta, and rewarded...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Bitter pill

Yeah, Bangkok Phuket has been exorbitant for years, and since Silirot was taken over by them its pri...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Bitter pill

Bangkok Hospital tried to charge me 2,700 baht for a 30 day supply of meds. They finally gave me the...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Bitter pill

now I only go the Bumrungrad, hospitals in Phuket cannot be trusted, patients are just cash cows to...(Read More)

Phuket Opinion: Bitter pill

After being given a false diagnosis for recurrent cancer based on suspect blood results, I had CT sc...(Read More)

Lottery office offers cash to nab dodgy vendors

Lottery Vendors,... the law is the law. When you have to pay yourself already 85 B for a ticket, you...(Read More)

Dengue fever epidemic declared

Finally! When Thai Government admits that there is a Dengue/Chikungunya Epidemic it is really saying...(Read More)

Police hunt for ’power cards’ agents

Were the cards not sold with illness curing guarantee? Hahaha....(Read More)

Thanathorn in Phuket hears local fishermen’s woes, critical island issues

Mr Thanatorn may also look into the matter that many thai fishing boats now sail under Myanmar Flag ...(Read More)