Login | Create Account Poll Currency Weather Facebook Youtube Search

Animal welfare bill ‘too vague’ – Phuket’s Soi Dog charity

PHUKET: Thailand’s National Legislative Assembly (NLA) yesterday (November 13) passed the first ever Animal Welfare Bill in the country, designed to punish people who abuse or neglect animals. The Bill was passed by a vote of 188-1, with four abstentions.

By The Phuket News

Friday 14 November 2014, 11:27AM

Dogs on the way to slaughter in jammed-full cages.

Dogs on the way to slaughter in jammed-full cages.

But the Phuket-based Soi Dog Foundation (SDF), which advised the NLA and is probably the most powerful lobby in Thailand for decent treatment of animals, today expressed disappointment that the new bill does not go far enough.

The legislation covers domesticated pets, animals raised for food, working animals, animals kept for entertainment purposes, wild animals in captivity and animals kept for any other purpose.

It prohibits cruel treatment of animals and stipulates that owners/carers must provide appropriate living conditions and a certain level of animal welfare.

The law allows police to enter homes and businesses to act on reports of animal cruelty. The maximum sentence for perpetrators is two years in jail and/or a B40,000 fine.

SDF Foundation co-founder and Vice President John Dalley, who advised the NLA on what should be included in the Bill, said “While welcoming the passing of Thailand’s first Animal Welfare Bill as a step in the right direction, SDF Foundation has serious concerns over the lack of clarity in the legislation.

“All other animal welfare laws throughout the world provide very specific guidelines to enable authorities to determine what is legal and what is illegal.”

He was referring specifically to a clause in the law which allows the killing of animals for food “which are usually considered as food”.

The committee responsible for reviewing the Bill stated that dogs and cats are not regarded as food in Thailand, and that therefore they are implicitly covered by the bill, but they have avoided explicitly stating which type of animals it will be illegal to kill for consumption.

Mr Dalley added, “It’s similar to introducing a law on driving too fast. Without specifying speed limits, the decision is left to individual police officers, and the courts, who may have different ideas as to whether a motorist was speeding or not. It is totally open to interpretation.”

The issue was raised at yesterday’s parliamentary meeting, and a notation added to this effect, meaning that in the future a committee that is to be formed to manage the law may consider clarifying the issue.

No mention is made in the law as to whether it is legal or illegal to kill a pet animal for its skin.

The northeast of Thailand, close to the border with Laos, is home to Thailand’s dog meat and dog skin trade which, according to the Thai Veterinary Medical Association, has seen up to 500,000 dogs a year slaughtered and processed in Thailand or Laos, or exported to Vietnam and China for human consumption.

The industry, SDF asserts, is run by organised criminal gangs and is worth up to US$25 million (B750 million) a year. The SDF has been at the forefront of a campaign to end the trade in Thailand in dogs for food or leather.

Mr Dalley concluded, “The only way a law can be measured for effectiveness is how it affects the level of crime it is meant to stop.

The coming months will indicate whether the authorities are able to enforce the law as it stands now. Without clear guidelines, we fear the authorities will be reluctant to act in many cases.”

The work of the SDF can been seen here and here. or



Person : Martin Turner

Comment on this story

* Please login to comment. If you do not have an account please register below by simply entering a username, password and email address. You can still leave your comment below at the same time.

Comments Here:
Comments Left:
# Characters

chazwolf | 16 November 2014 - 10:36:18

a pity the government does not bring in a similar act about people trafficking!

chazwolf | 16 November 2014 - 10:33:28

Yes they do a good job but the Aussie lady in charge is very "snappy" i think she needs more socialisation!

Elise | 15 November 2014 - 01:39:03

This law is not going to clean the bad image of Thailand for dog and cat owners, it's incredible that the government is COOPERATING with these CRIMINALS, slaughtering dogs and cats is illegal, they are not livestock, besides it's bad for public health, do they want to see an outbreak of rabies in their country for this?? how they can allow the eating of pets that are under criminal actions...

phuketdreaming | 14 November 2014 - 17:35:19

Soi Dog do a fantastic job please support them in any way you can, they have many great pets looking to get lucky with a new loving family. We have been lucky enough to have adopted one of there dogs a last year, also why can't the phuket news have a real active link to their web site at the bottom of the story? 

Have a news tip-off? Click here


Phuket community
Phuket Immigration to launch ‘Drive Thru’ service

Great laughing, a 90 day report like a Mc Donald drive through? See the number of people waiting in ...(Read More)

Immigration Chief Surachate to inspect new Phoenix salvage attempt

Yes .... perhaps hard to imagine for you, but foreigners called in to do a job thai can't do it ...(Read More)

Phuket Immigration to launch ‘Drive Thru’ service

So there will be a line of cars with the motors running, emitting exhaust fumes? This picture implie...(Read More)

Phuket Immigration to launch ‘Drive Thru’ service

Nice,if it would work ! Something i doubt....(Read More)

Immigration Chief Surachate to inspect new Phoenix salvage attempt

"He will be disappointed that the singaporean salvage team not will wai or take notice of him&q...(Read More)

Phuket Immigration to launch ‘Drive Thru’ service

Ah genuis..let the online reporting site be run down and waste 1000's of people 1000's of ho...(Read More)

Phuket Police ready for Loy Krathong

As many thai on Phuket go Lake Naiharn, let's see how authorities/RTP anticipate the enormous tr...(Read More)

Immigration Chief Surachate to inspect new Phoenix salvage attempt

Seems until now Immigration General becomes the highest authority to 'inspect' the disaster ...(Read More)

Amnesty strips Aung San Suu Kyi of highest honour

@ bojon. It was the latest of a string of awards she lost., including Canadian honorary citizenship...(Read More)